Search found 6497 matches

by SCIAG
24 Mar 2025 16:25
Forum: The Team
Topic: Under 10
Replies: 28
Views: 2108

Re: Under 10

Few more typos - the ones that jump out are Mikkel Andersen and Greg Halford. Mikkel is NOT a typo… https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mikkel_Andersen_(footballer) Presume you’re confusing him with Jokull Andresson who finally left last season. He never made a league appearance for Reading so is absent ...
by SCIAG
24 Mar 2025 16:12
Forum: The Team
Topic: Under 10
Replies: 28
Views: 2108

Re: Under 10

Few more typos - the ones that jump out are Mikkel Andersen and Greg Halford.

Sal Bibbo is a clear odd-one-out in that he still managed to be a hugely significant figure for the club, by being our goalkeeping coach for a decade or so when we had a string of good goalkeepers.
by SCIAG
21 Mar 2025 23:29
Forum: The Team
Topic: Glen Little > Kebe > Jobi
Replies: 14
Views: 1104

Re: Glen Little > Kebe > Jobi

Little was supremely talented, the great genius of our best-ever side. However, quite a lot of what that side did was set up around covering for his weaknesses. He got substituted off after an hour almost every week - a bit less unusual in those days when the bench was only five players and managers...
by SCIAG
20 Mar 2025 23:25
Forum: The Team
Topic: Ivar Ingimarsson > Tyler Bindon > Liam Moore (in his prime)
Replies: 30
Views: 2305

Re: Ivar Ingimarsson > Tyler Bindon > Liam Moore (in his prime)

Bindon hasn't had to face the same level of opposition that Ivar and Moore did. Lots of short-term players have just oozed class, Dariusz obviously, Zurab, Upson, Matt Miazga in his initial loan. Anton Ferdinand probably read the game better than anyone else but was never fit. My most controversial...
by SCIAG
20 Mar 2025 23:09
Forum: The Team
Topic: Dave Kitson > Shane Long > Kevin Doyle
Replies: 16
Views: 1136

Re: Dave Kitson > Shane Long > Kevin Doyle

Yeh, I've always felt like Doyle was right place at the right time. There was nothing particularly special about him, but he hit the ground running and never looked back. I still think that if we'd sold Doyle to Stoke instead of Kitson we'd have gone back up, first time of asking. That move ruined ...
by SCIAG
20 Mar 2025 14:16
Forum: The Team
Topic: Marcus Hahnemann > Shaka Hislop > Adam Federici
Replies: 25
Views: 2358

Re: Marcus Hahnemann > Shaka Hislop > Adam Federici

For me the only keeper who warrants comparison to Shaka is Al-Habsi. Hahnemann, Federici, and McCarthy all have their own strengths and weaknesses, all very good but not the miracle workers that Shaka and Al-Habsi were. That said, McCarthy against Liverpool is probably the best single performance I'...
by SCIAG
20 Mar 2025 14:11
Forum: The Team
Topic: Ivar Ingimarsson > Tyler Bindon > Liam Moore (in his prime)
Replies: 30
Views: 2305

Re: Ivar Ingimarsson > Tyler Bindon > Liam Moore (in his prime)

Bindon hasn't had to face the same level of opposition that Ivar and Moore did. Lots of short-term players have just oozed class, Dariusz obviously, Zurab, Upson, Matt Miazga in his initial loan. Anton Ferdinand probably read the game better than anyone else but was never fit. My most controversial ...
by SCIAG
20 Mar 2025 14:04
Forum: The Team
Topic: Gylfi Sigurdsson > Michael Olise > Steve Sidwell
Replies: 12
Views: 988

Re: Gylfi Sigurdsson > Michael Olise > Steve Sidwell

Sidwell is a completely different player.

Olise with us was a fraction of the player Gylfi was. Played 50% more matches but scored 50% fewer goals. Never looked quite as good as John Swift, who obviously was a worse version of Gylfi.
by SCIAG
20 Mar 2025 14:00
Forum: The Team
Topic: Dave Kitson > Shane Long > Kevin Doyle
Replies: 16
Views: 1136

Re: Dave Kitson > Shane Long > Kevin Doyle

Hard to say, all very different players. Although I'd say that Kitson is probably the best all-round striker I've ever seen play for us. Yeah. Doyle was consistently better than Long, who had one good season here, a couple including elsewhere. Quinn should be in the conversation. Prime Joao was as ...
by SCIAG
18 Mar 2025 23:03
Forum: The Team
Topic: Record Watch 2024/25
Replies: 205
Views: 87316

Re: Record Watch 2024/25

I've always found it a bit odd that people care about whether someone beats 106 at a lower level. For me it's always primarily been about the second tier of English football. If someone broke it in the top flight, especially with their shorter seasons, then yes we'd look a bit tinpot singing about t...
by SCIAG
01 Mar 2025 10:03
Forum: The Team
Topic: CONFIMRED - The final countdown
Replies: 8455
Views: 3912096

Re: CONFIMRED - This might be it!!

The regulations do say "this will be dependent upon the circumstances of the individual Club and will be determined by the League". So it can simultaneously be true that clubs under embargo are generally allowed to extend contracts, and also true that the League have decided our specific c...
by SCIAG
16 Feb 2025 07:57
Forum: The Team
Topic: The Academy/Development squads watch thread 2024/25
Replies: 8352
Views: 2841816

Re: The Academy/Development squads watch thread 2024/25

Thanks - he is of course Coke-Miles -Smith, who i didn’t realise was playing as i would have listed his proper name. Actually, that passed me by as well, although I had noticed that he sometimes only uses the first part of his triple-barrelled surname. Anyway, the red card was for two yellows, whic...
by SCIAG
12 Feb 2025 16:16
Forum: The Team
Topic: Phoenix Club: What would you pay
Replies: 49
Views: 13001

Re: Phoenix Club: What would you pay

Realistically I'd be too cynical about the notion. I'd be happier to pay a regular sustainable amount towards costs than to put up a large sum that would be swallowed up by operating costs within a year. I'd also be happy to contribute a fairly large sum towards a fundraiser that was going to sort a...
by SCIAG
11 Feb 2025 12:17
Forum: The Team
Topic: What records do Reading FC hold
Replies: 70
Views: 19607

Re: What records do Reading FC hold

The record for “scoring” the most league non-goals: Watford (a) 2008-09 Rochdale (h) 1975-76 Would this also mean an ex-Reading player has the record for not-scoring the most non-goals? Assuming someone was credited with scoring both of those goals The Watford goal was credited to John Eustace (own...
by SCIAG
10 Feb 2025 06:12
Forum: The Team
Topic: Ex Players
Replies: 3852
Views: 2281427

Re: Ex Players

Most dangerous opponent, for some… https://rdg.today/trent-alexander-arnold-names-forgotten-former-reading-fc-man-as-toughest-opponent-ever/ Made 4 apps for Reading, does anyone even remember him? https://i.ytimg.com/vi/zVjTxRcgbE8/maxresdefault.jpg Now without a club after leaving Morecambe last y...
by SCIAG
07 Feb 2025 10:15
Forum: The Team
Topic: Most valuable player
Replies: 7
Views: 4395

Re: Most valuable player

The transfer fee for Andy Carroll to Liverpool from Newcastle United in 2011 was £35 million At the time, this made Carroll the most expensive British footballer ever. Completely forgot about Carroll, and a lot of players of his vintage. Yeah, he’s up there with Drinkwater. £15m fee in his move to ...
by SCIAG
06 Feb 2025 18:51
Forum: The Team
Topic: Most valuable player
Replies: 7
Views: 4395

Re: Most valuable player

Yeah, Drinkwater has this comfortably. Les Ferdinand went for £6m twice. Anton Ferdinand was £8m for Sunderland. Baba Rahman was signed by Chelsea for £14m rising to £22m, though given how successful he was, one suspects it didn't actually rise. Similarly Piazon was £5m rising to £10m, so £5m. Wayne...
by SCIAG
05 Feb 2025 17:38
Forum: The Team
Topic: What records do Reading FC hold
Replies: 70
Views: 19607

Re: What records do Reading FC hold

Doesn’t ALF have the best goals per minutes played in the PL ? No, but he's close. Of retired players who have scored at least 7 goals, only Aguero and Henry are ahead of him. Among current players, Haaland and Duran are ahead of him. Duran is a similar case to Le Fondre, lots of goals from the ben...
by SCIAG
05 Feb 2025 15:42
Forum: The Team
Topic: What records do Reading FC hold
Replies: 70
Views: 19607

Re: What records do Reading FC hold

Highest league position by any club from Berkshire. Most defeats in the FA Cup for a league side. I think "Convey off, Hunt on" might have been a record for the most times one player has been substituted for another in league history, or at least in a season. Certainly it was some sort of ...
by SCIAG
04 Feb 2025 09:19
Forum: The Team
Topic: Confimred - Bindon to Nottingham Forest
Replies: 201
Views: 75938

Re: Confimred - Bindon to Nottingham Forest

Forest and their affiliates now have Bindon, Abbey, and Richards.

Have to say that’s a good back line for Rio Ave.
It is currently 10 Apr 2025 12:56