Shorey or Ingi

[Basingstoke Royal]

Who deserves it more????

[Yorkshire Royal]

I find neither that attractive.. Now Stephen Hunt with the Rambo hair... Phwoar....

[Slinky]

my vote will go to Hunt

[Basingstoke Royal]

[Turns8]

Hunty for me...he opitimises everything which is Reading FC...Spirit, apptitiude, application, never say die attitude, energy, good honest hardworking player and not some hyped up overpaid ego tripping so and so!!! (mentioning no names)...

The whole team have been awesome all season, but for me Hunty has shone above the rest..given he was written off long before the season had started...

[aaronrfc]

ingi. which is a shame cos iv always been a shorey fan

[Alan Partridge]

Hunt player of the year = LOL

Ingimarsson, Shorey, Sidwell.

[Royalee]

Ingimarsson - didn't think he'd be able to make the step up but have been proved wrong yet again by Mr Dependable.

Again, anyone putting Hunt anywhere near a player of the year award is having a laugh - effort yes, genuine class no.

[irishroyal81]

Ingimarsson - didn't think he'd be able to make the step up but have been proved wrong yet again by Mr Dependable.

Again, anyone putting Hunt anywhere near a player of the year award is having a laugh - effort yes, genuine class no.

I vote hunt too. What more does he have to do to prove he has genuine class??!! I think your having a laugh by disregarding his level of performances this year.

I base my decision on if the person was not in the team how would we have got on. On this basis I believe Hunt gave us balance, effort, skill, broke down attacks and summed up Reading Fc.

[Tinrib]

Ingimarsson - didn't think he'd be able to make the step up but have been proved wrong yet again by Mr Dependable.

Again, anyone putting Hunt anywhere near a player of the year award is having a laugh - effort yes, genuine class no.

I vote hunt too. What more does he have to do to prove he has genuine class??!! I think your having a laugh by disregarding his level of performances this year.

I base my decision on if the person was not in the team how would we have got on. On this basis I believe Hunt gave us balance, effort, skill, broke down attacks and summed up Reading Fc.

Nothing to do with regional allegiances then?

[irishroyal81]

biased?? me?? never!

[Royalee]

Ingimarsson - didn't think he'd be able to make the step up but have been proved wrong yet again by Mr Dependable.

Again, anyone putting Hunt anywhere near a player of the year award is having a laugh - effort yes, genuine class no.

I vote hunt too. What more does he have to do to prove he has genuine class??!! I think your having a laugh by disregarding his level of performances this year.

I base my decision on if the person was not in the team how would we have got on. On this basis I believe Hunt gave us balance, effort, skill, broke down attacks and summed up Reading Fc.

In order to prove his class, he might have to score sitters missed at Eastlands and The Valley, along with actually putting more than one cross into the box per game, given that he is a winger after all.

There's no doubting his effort, but effort is not always a direct reflection on overall performance.

[irishroyal81]

Ingimarsson - didn't think he'd be able to make the step up but have been proved wrong yet again by Mr Dependable.

Again, anyone putting Hunt anywhere near a player of the year award is having a laugh - effort yes, genuine class no.

I vote hunt too. What more does he have to do to prove he has genuine class??!! I think your having a laugh by disregarding his level of performances this year.

I base my decision on if the person was not in the team how would we have got on. On this basis I believe Hunt gave us balance, effort, skill, broke down attacks and summed up Reading Fc.

In order to prove his class, he might have to score sitters missed at Eastlands and The Valley, along with actually putting more than one cross into the box per game, given that he is a winger after all.

There's no doubting his effort, but effort is not always a direct reflection on overall performance.

I dont believe goal scoring to be the only level of whether a player is class or not. the general consenus here is that Glenn Little is class but yet has not scored this season.

I view Hunty as class as he gets himself into positions that other wingers do now. Sure enough he should have more goals this season (even though you could nearly credit the Goodison goal to him) I believe its his eagerness to get to the back post that gives him that extra edge. If the right winger attacked the back post like hunty does, hunty would have a lot more assists (does that make sense?!)

[Royalee]

Ingimarsson - didn't think he'd be able to make the step up but have been proved wrong yet again by Mr Dependable.

Again, anyone putting Hunt anywhere near a player of the year award is having a laugh - effort yes, genuine class no.

I vote hunt too. What more does he have to do to prove he has genuine class??!! I think your having a laugh by disregarding his level of performances this year.

I base my decision on if the person was not in the team how would we have got on. On this basis I believe Hunt gave us balance, effort, skill, broke down attacks and summed up Reading Fc.

In order to prove his class, he might have to score sitters missed at Eastlands and The Valley, along with actually putting more than one cross into the box per game, given that he is a winger after all.

There's no doubting his effort, but effort is not always a direct reflection on overall performance.

I dont believe goal scoring to be the only level of whether a player is class or not. the general consenus here is that Glenn Little is class but yet has not scored this season.

I view Hunty as class as he gets himself into positions that other wingers do now. Sure enough he should have more goals this season (even though you could nearly credit the Goodison goal to him) I believe its his eagerness to get to the back post that gives him that extra edge. If the right winger attacked the back post like hunty does, hunty would have a lot more assists (does that make sense?!)

No, because Hunt never manages to get crosses in to our centre forwards as it is, let alone anyone else.

[Focher]

Ingimarsson without a doubt, closely followed by Shorey.

If he'd played more this season then i have a feeling it would have been Gunnarsson though, the bloke for me is a genius, and shows what Reading Fc is all about, not Hunt as some have said.

[higher]

Hunty should be on the podium for his up and at em tenaciousness.Ingi first on my team sheet however.Reads the game so well.

[bigmike]

Ivar has is my player of the season.. hes the only Player to have played every second of the season so far and he has been a constant calming figure in defence

[lovetoscore]

Yep-Ivar has been class this season but Shorey has done well

[1871 Royal]

Where is the obviously needed 'Both' option

[West Stand Man]

Where is the obviously needed 'Both' option

Now that's an interesting thought!