Keep, Loan, Sell or Release Survey

[dakin1871]

Now we have decided who to sell ect. any names people would want to join the club to replace the leavers?

You do realise that these results aren't binding for the club?

Yeah I know that!! was just wondering if anyone had any thoughts on possible signings they wanted to (realistically) see??

[shaka's shorts]

I'll update the results later, well over 1000 now

[shaka's shorts]

We now have 1131 entries. So, I have updated the results (see below for the new scores).

Here they are in full: All scores rounded up to nearest % & ignoring the don't knows unless they are a over 5% (which is why they don't all add up to 100%)

The update only changes the scores a little. The scores are slightly worse for McAnuff & Pog and there are a few more don't knows around.

Keepers:
McCarthy Keep 97%, Loan 0%, Sell 3%
Feds Keep 31%, Loan 1%, Sell 65%
Taylor Keep 32%, Loan 5%, Sell & Release (he is out of contract) 61%
Andersen Keep 54%, Loan 24%, Sell 17%, Release 3%
Henly Keep 31%, Loan 57%, Sell 1%, Release 1%

Full Backs:
Harte Keep 6%, Sell & Release combined 93%
Shorey Keep 20%, Sell & Release comb 79%
Kelly Keep 95%, Loan 1%, Sell 4%
Gunter Keep 92%, Loan 1%, Sell 7%
Cummings Keep 73%, Loan 11%, Sell 13%, Release 1%
Arnold keep 18%, Loan 58%, Sell 1%, Release 1% (don't knows 22%)

Centre Backs:
Gorkss Keep 11%, Loan 1%, Sell 55%, Release 24%
Pearce Keep 33%, Loan 1%, Sell& Release combined 64%
Morrison Keep 98%, Loan 1%, Sell 1%
Mariappa Keep 99%, Sell 1%
Hector keep 44%, Loan 44%, Sell 1%, Release 1% (don't know 10%)
Sweeney 19%, Loan 64%, Sell 1%, Release 2% (don't know 14%)

Wingers:
McAnuff Keep 72%, Loan 1%, Sell 24%, Release 2%
Kebe Keep 69%, Sell 29%, Release 1%
McCleary Keep 97%, Loan 1%, Sell 2%
HRK Keep 96%, Loan 1%, Sell 3%
Obita Keep 63%, Loan 33%, Sell 1%

Midfield:
Karacan Keep 94%, Sell 5%
Guthrie Keep 92%, Sell 7%
Carrico Keep 93%, Loan 2%, Sell 3%
Akpan Keep 91%, Loan 6%, Sell 2%
Ledge Keep 14%, Loan 1%, Sell 66%, Release 17%
Tabb Keep 13%, Loan 2%, Sell & Release comb 85%
Taylor Keep 15%, Loan 52%, Sell & Release comb 26%
D'Ath Keep 22%, Loan 64%, Sell 5%, Release 5%

Striker:
Pog Keep 32%, Sell 61%, Release 5%
Hunt Keep 24%, Loan 1%, Sell & Release comb 72%
ALF Keep 93%, Sell 7%
Blackman Keep 71%, Loan 13%, Sell 13%, Release 1%
Roberts Keep 38%, Sell 14%, Release 45%
Church Keep 5%, Loan 3%, Sell & Release comb 92%
Samuel Keep 40%, Loan 48%, Sell 2%, Release 3% (don't know 8%)

So, in SUMMARY, you want to:
Keep: McCarthy, Andersen, Kelly, Gunter, Cummings, Mariappa, Morrison, Hector, McAnuff, Kebe, HRK, McCleary, Karacan, Carrico, Guthrie, Akpan Obita, ALF & Blackman (19 players)
Loan: Henly, Arnold, Sweeney, D'Ath, J Taylor & Samuel (6) - Looks like we got Henly, Arnold & D'Ath correct too as they have been offered deals.
Sell: Federici, Gorkss, Ledge & Pog (4)
Release: S Taylor, Harte, Shorey, Pearce, Tabb, Hunt & Church (7). We got 6 out of 7. I was surprised to see us offering Stuart Taylor a contract..... Also, missing out Joseph Mills was probably the right thing to do as he has been released along with Brett Williams, who I also left out!

[Davezk]

Surprised to see people wanted McAnuff to be sold. He'll do a decent job in the Championship and to be honest he was one of our better performers this season IMO.

[shaka's shorts]

McAnuff seems to be unfairly criticized by many to me too. I guess it comes with being Captain.

[andrew1957]

Surprised to see people wanted McAnuff to be sold. He'll do a decent job in the Championship and to be honest he was one of our better performers this season IMO.

I would agree he has been under appreciated and I voted for him as POTS BUT if we get promoted again, he will be getting a good bit older and did not really shoot the lights out at PL level and so if we were offered say 500K by QPR I would take it as it would be good for us and good for him (extended contract/more security) and look to younger options. We already have Kebe, HRK and McCleary and perhaps Obita or Edwards could start having a go off the bench.

Hence I voted to sell.