I was at virtually every home game from the 2005-06 and 2006-07 seasons so have been lucky enough to see quite a few special ones
I was pretty young at the time of the play off semi win vs Wigan and Forster's winner but I'm sure that would rank highly if I had been there. My first ever game was actually in that season and I saw Graeme Murty's only other Reading goal aside from THAT penalty, it was good strike from range as well, but sadly we went on to lose 3-1 and I cried on the way home
One of the earliest top quality goals I can remember was one of Cureton's volleys, against Brighton in 2003 except that was a consolation as we also ended up losing that too. On a more positive note I remember Kitson's two goals in the 2-0 over West Ham on Pardew's return felt pretty good, he also got a hat trick against them at home the following season in a 3-1 win although I wasn't there for that one.
Anyway, some favourites from the 2 golden years -
05/06Convey vs Millwall
Lita vs Palace
Gunnarsson's 2nd (winning goal) vs Sheffield Utd
Doyle vs Hull
Little vs Hull
All the goals from the 5-1 win vs Cardiff
Lita's 2nd vs West Brom (FA Cup)
All the goals from the 4-0 win vs Norwich
Lita vs Preston
All the goals from the 5-0 win vs Derby (CHAMPIONS)
Murty vs QPR (RECORD BREAKERS)
06/07All the goals (especially Lita's winner) from the 3-2 win vs Middlesbrough
Ingimarsson vs Man City
Doyle vs Man Utd
Shorey vs Spurs
Seol vs Charlton
All the goals from the 6-0 win vs West Ham
De La Cruz vs Sheffield Utd
Sidwell's 2nd vs Aston Villa
Since 2007-08 I've only been to no more than a handful of games at the Mad Stad each season, sometimes just one, usually just do away games now and not many goals at home stick out since then but I do remember an opening day rocket by Manset against Millwall and also Le Fondre scored a nice volley vs Watford a couple of seasons ago. Then of course there was Leigertwood vs Forest as that sent us back up.
Wasn't there for HRK vs Man Utd or Le Fondre's two against Chelsea but they were quality goals as well and I'm probably forgetting some others. I'm actually going to Mad Stad on Saturday for the match vs MK Dons though, so lets hope there's a Reading goal to remember...