Shorey...

[Behindu]

Not hw the commentetors saw it TF !
They were saying how well the entire defence had played (for 68 minutes at least....)

Then the "commentetors" were wrong.

Lescott was clearly at fault for the winner.

Not sure there is any logic linking your two statements....

[Avon Royal]

Not hw the commentetors saw it TF !
They were saying how well the entire defence had played (for 68 minutes at least....)

Then the "commentetors" were wrong.

Lescott was clearly at fault for the winner.

Not sure there is any logic linking your two statements....

Then you're wrong as well!

[Behindu]

Not hw the commentetors saw it TF !
They were saying how well the entire defence had played (for 68 minutes at least....)

Then the "commentetors" were wrong.

Lescott was clearly at fault for the winner.

Not sure there is any logic linking your two statements....

Then you're wrong as well!

Only if you can provide the logic...

[Top Flight]

Not hw the commentetors saw it TF !
They were saying how well the entire defence had played (for 68 minutes at least....)

What do the commentators know? They just speak sh*te for the sake of it half the time!

[Behindu]

Not hw the commentetors saw it TF !
They were saying how well the entire defence had played (for 68 minutes at least....)

What do the commentators know? They just speak sh*te for the sake of it half the time!

What do HNA posters know ....

[Top Flight]

England would have won if Shorey had played against Russia.

Flippin Lescott was at fault for the Russian winner. Shorey would have been first to the ball.

Also that Russian geezer skinned Lescott a couple of times. If Shorey had played England would have defended better on the flank and would have had more attacking flair going forward.

McLaren really FFffd it up this time by leaving Shorey out.

Most subjective RTG comment in the history of hobnob.

Words fail me.

Not really......... Its the truth.

For some strange reason, as soon as it becomes clear one of our players want to leave. The fans suddenly change their opinions immediately. If Shorey was 100% committed to RFC at the moment and he publicly said he was staying then you just wouldn't see all these negative comments about Shorey's performances on this board. The tone would be alot more positive.

I guess Reading fans are psychologically preparing for a future team that doesn't contain our left sided wonder kid. The most cultured left foot ever to have played for Reading!

These types of comments surrounded Sidwell in the lead up to his departure as well.

Sidwell was a great player for RFC but the fans no longer recognise that. Shorey has been fantastic for the Royals as well. But again the fans are starting to stop recognising it. Its sad really.

[Behindu]

It's an opinion !

And where are all these negative comments about Shorey ?
He's not having a great season, that's obvious. Doesn;t make him a bad player.
And i don;t think he's going anywhere in January.

[Oi Oi Saveloy]

England would have won if Shorey had played against Russia.

Flippin Lescott was at fault for the Russian winner. Shorey would have been first to the ball.

Also that Russian geezer skinned Lescott a couple of times. If Shorey had played England would have defended better on the flank and would have had more attacking flair going forward.

McLaren really FFffd it up this time by leaving Shorey out.

Most subjective RTG comment in the history of hobnob.

Words fail me.

Not really......... Its the truth.

For some strange reason, as soon as it becomes clear one of our players want to leave. The fans suddenly change their opinions immediately. If Shorey was 100% committed to RFC at the moment and he publicly said he was staying then you just wouldn't see all these negative comments about Shorey's performances on this board. The tone would be alot more positive.

I guess Reading fans are psychologically preparing for a future team that doesn't contain our left sided wonder kid. The most cultured left foot ever to have played for Reading!

It was your suggestion that we would have won the game had Shorey played I found hard to swollow.

My comment has nothing to do with the slating Shorey becuase he might want to leave and his sebsequent performances.

[Top Flight]

It's an opinion !

And where are all these negative comments about Shorey ?
He's not having a great season, that's obvious. Doesn;t make him a bad player.
And i don;t think he's going anywhere in January.

They're everywhere.

[Top Flight]

England would have won if Shorey had played against Russia.

Flippin Lescott was at fault for the Russian winner. Shorey would have been first to the ball.

Also that Russian geezer skinned Lescott a couple of times. If Shorey had played England would have defended better on the flank and would have had more attacking flair going forward.

McLaren really FFffd it up this time by leaving Shorey out.

Most subjective RTG comment in the history of hobnob.

Words fail me.

Not really......... Its the truth.

For some strange reason, as soon as it becomes clear one of our players want to leave. The fans suddenly change their opinions immediately. If Shorey was 100% committed to RFC at the moment and he publicly said he was staying then you just wouldn't see all these negative comments about Shorey's performances on this board. The tone would be alot more positive.

I guess Reading fans are psychologically preparing for a future team that doesn't contain our left sided wonder kid. The most cultured left foot ever to have played for Reading!

It was your suggestion that we would have won the game had Shorey played I found hard to swollow.

My comment has nothing to do with the slating Shorey becuase he might want to leave and his sebsequent performances.

Its time to wear those rose tinted spectacles again. Why have people taken them off now?

[Oi Oi Saveloy]

England would have won if Shorey had played against Russia.

Flippin Lescott was at fault for the Russian winner. Shorey would have been first to the ball.

Also that Russian geezer skinned Lescott a couple of times. If Shorey had played England would have defended better on the flank and would have had more attacking flair going forward.

McLaren really FFffd it up this time by leaving Shorey out.

Most subjective RTG comment in the history of hobnob.

Words fail me.

Not really......... Its the truth.

For some strange reason, as soon as it becomes clear one of our players want to leave. The fans suddenly change their opinions immediately. If Shorey was 100% committed to RFC at the moment and he publicly said he was staying then you just wouldn't see all these negative comments about Shorey's performances on this board. The tone would be alot more positive.

I guess Reading fans are psychologically preparing for a future team that doesn't contain our left sided wonder kid. The most cultured left foot ever to have played for Reading!

It was your suggestion that we would have won the game had Shorey played I found hard to swollow.

My comment has nothing to do with the slating Shorey becuase he might want to leave and his sebsequent performances.

Its time to wear those rose tinted spectacles again. Why have people taken them off now?

Forget the rose tinted spectacles. I would rather have watched the second half blind-folded.

[rg6royal]

don't see why lescott got ahead of shorey to play left back.

[Oi Oi Saveloy]

don't see why lescott got ahead of shorey to play left back.

In which case it's probably past your bed time.

[Behindu]

It's an opinion !

And where are all these negative comments about Shorey ?
He's not having a great season, that's obvious. Doesn;t make him a bad player.
And i don;t think he's going anywhere in January.

They're everywhere.

There's a difference between negative and objective !
Anyone who thinks Shorey is on top form isn't being 'positive', they are either blind, stupid or desperate (to borrow a phrase).
Doesn;t make Shorey a bad player to say he's had a little dip in form and it's not negative to acknowledge that he played better last season.

[rg6royal]

don't see why lescott got ahead of shorey to play left back.

In which case it's probably past your bed time.

bed time at 10 mate

[Top Flight]

It's an opinion !

And where are all these negative comments about Shorey ?
He's not having a great season, that's obvious. Doesn;t make him a bad player.
And i don;t think he's going anywhere in January.

They're everywhere.

There's a difference between negative and objective !
Anyone who thinks Shorey is on top form isn't being 'positive', they are either blind, stupid or desperate (to borrow a phrase).Doesn;t make Shorey a bad player to say he's had a little dip in form and it's not negative to acknowledge that he played better last season.

If you say so.

[Muskrat]

Player rating taken from Daily Mail for Lestcott:

JOLEON LESCOTT: Everton man took some time to settle on his first start for England. Was often drawn inside, and could perhaps have reacted quicker at second Russia goal - 5.

That was the lowest rating of any of the team, including Robinson

I personally think McClown got it wrong by not playing a specialist left back in that position but what do I know?

To follow the current trend (which is not something I do very often), Shorey>Lescott at left back.

[Behindu]

Anyone who thinks Shorey is on top form isn't being 'positive', they are either blind, stupid or desperate (to borrow a phrase).Doesn;t make Shorey a bad player to say he's had a little dip in form and it's not negative to acknowledge that he played better last season.

If you say so.[/quote]

No, make the case for him being in outstanding form - it's open to debate.
If you can convince me that the Shorey of this season is an improvement on Shorey of last season or the season before then I'd be delighted.

I'd also be prepared to let you convince me the moon is made of cheese and Boris Johnson will be the next president of the USA...

[MartinRdg]

Not hw the commentetors saw it TF !
They were saying how well the entire defence had played (for 68 minutes at least....)

Then the "commentetors" were wrong.

Lescott was clearly at fault for the winner.

And not only that but what was Rooney doing playing as a left back when he "gave" away the penalty? Where was Lescott?

[Behindu]

Having now seen the pen on TV it was a correct decision.
First contact outside the box but also contact inside. Penalty.