Harper or Sidwell

Fife · by **Fife** » 10 Jun 2006 20:03

I think Harper is more loyal but Sidwell has more quality.

All 5 goals · by **All 5 goals** » 10 Jun 2006 21:16

At the moment Sidwell if we but another box to box midfielder (I heard Lampard's partner wants to move our of London) who can impose himself in midfield then Harper.

Harper is the more telented and exciting player.

Sidwell is the more consistent and 'English' type of Midfielder.

SouthDownsRoyal · by **SouthDownsRoyal** » 16 Nov 2006 21:52

Sidwell so far this season.

Lower West · by **Lower West** » 16 Nov 2006 22:51

Harper.

Reading Abbey · by **Reading Abbey** » 17 Nov 2006 08:30

Harps.

pieface · by **pieface** » 17 Nov 2006 10:25

Sidwell to many times ive seen harper refuse autographs to little kids

Alan Partridge · by **Alan Partridge** » 17 Nov 2006 10:26

LOL @ those going for Harper

Harps stay sharp · by **Harps stay sharp** » 17 Nov 2006 12:47

When I saw this thread I thought here we go, Sid has a good game so the daggers are out for our Harps.

How wrong could I be. It's refreshing to see how many people appreciate Harps' tireless running and pivotal midfield play.

peeping_bernal · by **peeping_bernal** » 17 Nov 2006 14:04

Got to be Harper, he does so much without be noticed as he is not a flair player but an effective player. He spends the whole game organising and instructing players around him,and in the last 2 years he has even learn't how to tackle. A captain of the future and a good servant to the club.

brendywendy · by **brendywendy** » 17 Nov 2006 16:20

yup i agree

if thered been a gunnarson button id have pressed that instead

but harps just shades it for me, purely on th ebasis of his comedy eyebrows

Don Finch · by **Don Finch** » 17 Nov 2006 17:07

All 5 goals At the moment Sidwell if we but another box to box midfielder (I heard Lampard's partner wants to move our of London) who can impose himself in midfield then Harper.

I'd rather bring Caskey out of retirement than watch that fat cnut wearing the hoops. One good season does not a good player make.

MC ROYAL · by **MC ROYAL** » 17 Nov 2006 23:04

Alan Partridge LOL @ those going for Harper

Why? I went for Harper, he runs all day, rarely gives the ball away, and sprays the ball about well.

The whole year inn · by **The whole year inn** » 17 Nov 2006 23:31

Alan Partridge LOL @ those going for Harper

Had me wondering too.

jon56565 · by **jon56565** » 18 Nov 2006 11:18

my vote goes to john oster

The_Cat · by **The_Cat** » 18 Nov 2006 11:21

Is this on or off the pitch?

ferret · by **ferret** » 18 Nov 2006 11:27

Sidwell for me as Harper just make enough goals. I cant belive he did'nt even get one assist last season, even Lita managed a few.

Branfoot Out · by **Branfoot Out** » 18 Nov 2006 18:14

Sidwell breaks up the play and wins the ball superbly (West Ham and Tottenham being prime examples of him at the top of his game). Absolutely invaluable in giving us possession. Can't afford to lose him. Brilliant today again.

Reading_Royal · by **Reading_Royal** » 18 Nov 2006 21:47

a few people on here were saying they prefer harps as he's a loyal royal, but did he say last season that if reading didn't get promoted then he would be playing in the prem without reading anyway because he could go to west ham. or was that a joke of his i missed the point.

Also how about when harps embraced poll and looked like he was going to give him a kiss if he gave us a corner instead of the goalkick

Still voted sidders though.

Royal Gunner · by **Royal Gunner** » 19 Nov 2006 10:47

Harps

M4 Junction 11 · by **M4 Junction 11** » 06 Dec 2006 21:00

tonight harps

Harper or Sidwell

Harper or Sidwell

Who is online