by Sutekh »
26 Oct 2020 19:13
SWLR STAR Liaison Snowball
Most FA Cup goals conceded: 539: Aston Villa
Highest FA Cup goal difference: +305: Aston Villa
Most FA Cup games played: 455: Arsenal
Most FA Cup games won: 251: Manchester United
Most FA Cup games lost: 130: Notts County <<<<<<<<<<<<<,
Most FA Cup games drawn: 103: Arsenal
But Ian will know different
Very late to the thread (red card?) and not being Ian - but some developments on this record.
Reading and Notts Co both first entered the FA Cup in 1877. Notts won it in 1894 therefore Reading have been eliminated more times than any other League club as we haven;t ever won it. Furthermore, Notts are no longer a league club so that means at the moment it's ours - yippee.
Marlow have entered every single year since 1871 so they should hold most FA Cup defeats for ANY club. One of Reading's eliminations wasn't a defeat but a withdrawal v Marlow in 1882 (?) - so that's why Notts may have got the nod in the record book. AND YET just this weekend (2020) Notts withdrew from their cup tie v King's Lynn
Some FA Cup databases are not all they're cracked up to be - witness last month one fan claiming a hat-trick of unrecorded goals in a 6-0 Reading win in 1893 that the FA had as 3-0.
On a couple more records:
- we still hold the EFL record for longest time without conceding - Death's record from 1979 - though Van der Saar has the all-comers and PL record
- I think we hold longest unbeaten run in the second tier - of 34 games, jointly with Liverpool
Guess Notts County refers to most games lost by a team in the Football League at the time. As they joined league on formation in 1888, and were relegated in 2019, less one year they won it = 130 losses. HTH
Not sure that 130 is right (or it’s an old statistic)
Basically
The FACup began in 1871/72, 149 “years” ago
There have been 139 competitions played since (no competitions were held in 1915/16, 1916/17, 1917/18, 1918/19, 1939/40, 1940/41, 1941/42, 1942/43, 1943/44, 1944/45 (10 “years” in total))
Notts County (and Reading) first entered in 1877/78 (in the 7th competition) and therefore have competed in 133 competitions
Reading withdrew in 1882 and therefore have only competed (and lost) in 132 competitions
Notts County won the competition in 1894 and have therefore also lost in 132 competitions (though their withdrawal this season now means they have only lost in 131 competitions
Therefore Reading can be proud
to say they have lost in the FA Cup more times than any other league side.