Sidwell Replacement - Who would you go for?

[Huntley & Palmer]

More likely back to France I would say, he certainly would not be interested in a move here.

[brendywendy]

James Harper to play a more attacking role??? you must be kidding yourselves surely? Harper can't slice open a cake let alone a defence and his shooting is atrocious.

5 times better than sidwells , at least, who is apparenty good enough for a top four team, and the england squad!!
harps is an attacking midfielder who has been hamstrung having to share the defensive duties with sids all these years,


Gunnarsson is the type of player who would be good in central midfield for us though finding a partner is more difficult.
we have both harper and oster as attacking options to gunnarson defensive one.would still need one more though i suppose


Emerse Fae...will be go back in for him?

[Handsome Man]

Harper will replace Sidwell brilliantly.
He will shine next year.

In my fantasies I would love to see somebody like Song join us, and maybe even Reo-Coker, but I think it will be a mix of Gunnarson and Halford.

I do think Flamini is completely shit though.

Did you go to Charlton?

Song is shite. Flamini will want a move to a bigger team.

I think Wenger will hold onto Song a lot tighter than Flamini.

[spickroyal]

I think Jagielka would be great for us if Sheff U get relegated - I'd be prepared to pay up to 4-5 million to get him as well...

Wow, that is extremely generous of you. Contact the club, I'm sure they'll take you up on it.

[Basingstoke Royal]

Harper will replace Sidwell brilliantly.
He will shine next year.

In my fantasies I would love to see somebody like Song join us, and maybe even Reo-Coker, but I think it will be a mix of Gunnarson and Halford.

I do think Flamini is completely shit though.

Did you go to Charlton?

Song is shite. Flamini will want a move to a bigger team.

I think Wenger will hold onto Song a lot tighter than Flamini.

Flamini wont settle to rot in the Arsenal reserves.

Did you think Song looked good the other night then? Totally outclassed by Sidwell, so a backward step in my opinion.

[Hoop Blah]

I've just gone back and watched Giles Barnes' goals, he certainly scores crackers!

[readingfc_4_life_and_beyo]

I've just gone back and watched Giles Barnes' goals, he certainly scores crackers!

So 'does' Halford.

[Archie's penalty]

I think Jagielka would be great for us if Sheff U get relegated - I'd be prepared to pay up to 4-5 million to get him as well...

Wow, that is extremely generous of you. Contact the club, I'm sure they'll take you up on it.

Guffaw guffaw

[beno]

Bjorn Heidenstrom

John Gregg

[weybridgewanderer]

Scott brown at Hibs?

barry ferguson at rangers?

[Tilehurst End]

Robbie Savage

[bcubed]

Frank Lampard.

wouldn't this generate the age old question of whether Lampard can play in the same team as Harper?

[Barry the bird boggler]

Jimmy Bullard is great call, might be in with a chance as well if Fulham go down.

Steve (Sean?) Davis at Aston Villa is another talent I like the look of....

[hughsies no.1]

Flamini- £2m-£3m
Barnes-£6m
Bullard-£3m
O'neill-£3m
Davis-£1.5m

BRYN - PRICELESS


The man in my eyes has been one of the best players this season and has been so unlucky not to get a starting role. we obviously are going to be short in the centre of midfield so getting someone in is a main priority but i really feel bryn should be put in, oster and karacan and even Halford should also be considered.

[Coppell's Right Footed 11]

Jimmy Bullard is great call, might be in with a chance as well if Fulham go down.

Steve (Sean?) Davis at Aston Villa is another talent I like the look of....

Bullard will struggle to find himself again IMO...i have suffered a similar injury to him and i can't actually play play in matches etc anymore. By dislocating the knee cap and ripping his cruciates his knee joint has been open and will never be the same strength it once was. I very much doubt you will see the tackling side as much anymore from Bullard..but if we do then it won't take long for Bullard to be out for a long time again by suffering a recurrence

[Leamington Royal]

I agree with the Olofinjana shout. Remember him 2 years ago in the last home game of the season and he absolutely bossed the game from CM. Does anyone know how he's come on since - I know he was out injured for a while.

[Stranded]

Flamini- £2m-£3m
Barnes-£6m
Bullard-£3m
O'neill-£3m
Davis-£1.5m

BRYN - PRICELESS


The man in my eyes has been one of the best players this season and has been so unlucky not to get a starting role. we obviously are going to be short in the centre of midfield so getting someone in is a main priority but i really feel bryn should be put in, oster and karacan and even Halford should also be considered.

The thing with Bryn (and I love him to bits as a player) is that it's easier to look great playing the odd game here and there - would he look as good, be as effective if he was playing every week? I'm not overly sure.

[Wycombe Royal]

I agree with the Olofinjana shout. Remember him 2 years ago in the last home game of the season and he absolutely bossed the game from CM. Does anyone know how he's come on since - I know he was out injured for a while.

I didn't think the Wolves fans rated him that highly, certainly not for the amount he cost them.

[Irvinchangeyaname]

I do think Flamini is completely shit though.

Have to disagree but I think he'll move to a team that can at least offer UEFA Cup football if not Champions League.

He'll only have to wait one season for that with us

[mortimer royal]

who's playing for cork at the moment?