Player Ratings

[Bill Oddie's Beard]

I've been asked by 4-4-2 to give individual player ratings for each of our players. I thought I'd see if I could get a general view from you guys rather than giving my own tainted opinion.

So, what d'ya reckon?

TALENTSPOTTER PLAYER RATINGS
Every player needs an overall FourFourTwo rating (1-10), plus individual ratings (also 1-10) for each of their skill categories. Ratings must be whole numbers.

Marcus Hahnemann
Overall ability
Shotstopping
Crosses
Distribution
Saving penalties
Presence
Positioning

Graeme Murty
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Nicky Shorey
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Kalifa Cisse
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Ibrahima Sonko
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Brynjar Gunnarsson
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Leroy Lita
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Kevin Doyle
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Stephen Hunt
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Dave Kitson
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

James Harper
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Ivar Ingimarsson
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Bobby Convey
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling


Liam Rosenior
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Andre Bikey
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

Shane Long
Overall ability
Shooting
Passing
Crossing
Tackling
Pace
Work-rate
Creativity
Heading
Dribbling

[Huntley & Palmer]

That is far too long to bother reading

[Kevin Doyles Right Foot]

Cba to write that all out

[Hoop Blah]

If you cant be bothered to do it yourself just tell them where to go

[swickle09]

That is far too long to bother reading

Greed

[Bill Oddie's Beard]

If you cant be bothered to do it yourself just tell them where to go

Pretty much why I was hoping you lot would do my dirty work for me...

We could have turned them into top trumps, it was gonna be so much fun

[brendywendy]

I've been asked by 4-4-2 to give individual player ratings for each of our players. I thought I'd see if I could get a general view from you guys rather than giving my own tainted opinion.

So, what d'ya reckon?

TALENTSPOTTER PLAYER RATINGS
Every player needs an overall FourFourTwo rating (1-10), plus individual ratings (also 1-10) for each of their skill categories. Ratings must be whole numbers.

Marcus Hahnemann
Overall ability-7
Shotstopping-8
Crosses-6
Distribution-6
Saving penalties-6
Presence- 7
Positioning- 7

Graeme Murty
Overall ability-6
Shooting-5
Passing-6
Crossing-7
Tackling-7
Pace-6
Work-rate-7
Creativity-6
Heading-7
Dribbling-6

Nicky Shorey
Overall ability-7
Shooting--7
Passing-8
Crossing-8
Tackling-7
Pace-6
Work-rate-7
Creativity-7
Heading-7
Dribbling7

Kalifa Cisse
Overall ability-6
Shooting -6
Passing-7
Crossing-6
Tackling-7
Pace-7
Work-rate-7
Creativity-7
Heading-5
Dribbling-6

Ibrahima Sonko
Overall ability-6
Shooting-5
Passing-6
Crossing-5
Tackling-8
Pace-7
Work-rate-7
Creativity-5
Heading-8
Dribbling-6

Brynjar Gunnarsson
Overall ability-7
Shooting -8
Passing-7
Crossing-7
Tackling-7
Pace-4
Work-rate-6
Creativity-6
Heading-8
Dribbling-5

Leroy Lita
Overall ability-7
Shooting -7
Passing-6
Crossing-6
Tackling-6
Pace-7
Work-rate-6
Creativity-7
Heading-7
Dribbling-7

Kevin Doyle
Overall ability-8
Shooting-8
Passing-7
Crossing-7
Tackling-7
Pace-8
Work-rate-8
Creativity-7
Heading-8
Dribbling-7

Stephen Hunt
Overall ability-7
Shooting - 6
Passing- 6
Crossing-6
Tackling-7
Pace-7
Work-rate-10
Creativity-7
Heading-7
Dribbling-6

Dave Kitson
Overall ability-8
Shooting -8
Passing-8
Crossing-7
Tackling-7
Pace-7
Work-rate-7
Creativity-8
Heading-8
Dribbling-7

James Harper
Overall ability-7
Shooting-7
Passing-8
Crossing-7
Tackling-5
Pace-7
Work-rate-9
Creativity-7
Heading-7
Dribbling-7

Ivar Ingimarsson
Overall ability-7
Shooting -6
Passing-7
Crossing-6
Tackling-7
Pace-5
Work-rate-8
Creativity-7
Heading-8
Dribbling-6

Bobby Convey
Overall ability-7
Shooting-7
Passing-7
Crossing-8
Tackling-5
Pace-7
Work-rate-7
Creativity-7
Heading-6
Dribbling-7


Liam Rosenior
Overall ability-6
Shooting - 5
Passing-6
Crossing-6
Tackling-7
Pace-7
Work-rate-7
Creativity-7
Heading-7
Dribbling-6

Andre Bikey
Overall ability-8
Shooting -7
Passing-7
Crossing-7
Tackling-9
Pace-8
Work-rate-7
Creativity-7
Heading-8
Dribbling-7

Shane Long
Overall ability 6/7
Shooting-7
Passing-6
Crossing-7
Tackling-6
Pace-7
Work-rate-7
Creativity-6
Heading-7
Dribbling

all my scores are probably slightly higher than the consensus on here though

[Alan Partridge]

ALOL @ Sonko dribbling 6

If our players were as good as those ratings we'd have finished 10th.

[Ian Royal]

I've been asked by 4-4-2 to give individual player ratings for each of our players. I thought I'd see if I could get a general view from you guys rather than giving my own tainted opinion.

So, what d'ya reckon?

TALENTSPOTTER PLAYER RATINGS
Every player needs an overall FourFourTwo rating (1-10), plus individual ratings (also 1-10) for each of their skill categories. Ratings must be whole numbers.

Marcus Hahnemann
Overall ability 8
Shotstopping 8
Crosses 6
Distribution 7
Saving penalties 6
Presence 8
Positioning 8

Graeme Murty
Overall ability 7
Shooting 3
Passing 6
Crossing 7
Tackling 7
Pace 6
Work-rate 9
Creativity 6
Heading 6
Dribbling 6

Nicky Shorey
Overall ability 8
Shooting 7
Passing 8
Crossing 8
Tackling 6
Pace 6
Work-rate 7
Creativity 8
Heading 6
Dribbling 7

Kalifa Cisse
Overall ability 6
Shooting 5
Passing 6
Crossing 5
Tackling 6
Pace 6
Work-rate 6
Creativity 4
Heading 4
Dribbling 6

Ibrahima Sonko
Overall ability 7
Shooting 4
Passing 5
Crossing 3
Tackling 8
Pace 7
Work-rate 7
Creativity 3
Heading 7
Dribbling 4

Brynjar Gunnarsson
Overall ability 6
Shooting 7
Passing 6
Crossing 5
Tackling 6
Pace 4
Work-rate 6
Creativity 5
Heading 6
Dribbling 6

Leroy Lita
Overall ability 7
Shooting 9
Passing 7
Crossing 6
Tackling 4
Pace 7
Work-rate 6
Creativity 7
Heading 7
Dribbling 7

Kevin Doyle
Overall ability 8
Shooting 7
Passing 7
Crossing 7
Tackling 5
Pace 8
Work-rate 8
Creativity 8
Heading 7
Dribbling 7

Stephen Hunt
Overall ability 6
Shooting 6
Passing 6
Crossing 6
Tackling 6
Pace 7
Work-rate 8
Creativity 6
Heading 6
Dribbling 6

Dave Kitson
Overall ability 9
Shooting 8
Passing 9
Crossing 7
Tackling 6
Pace 6
Work-rate 7
Creativity 9
Heading 8
Dribbling 7

James Harper
Overall ability 8
Shooting 7
Passing 8
Crossing 7
Tackling 5
Pace 8
Work-rate 8
Creativity 7
Heading 5
Dribbling 7

Ivar Ingimarsson
Overall ability 7
Shooting 6
Passing 7
Crossing 5
Tackling 7
Pace 5
Work-rate 7
Creativity 5
Heading 7
Dribbling 6

Bobby Convey
Overall ability 7
Shooting 6
Passing 7
Crossing 7
Tackling 5
Pace 7
Work-rate 6
Creativity 7
Heading 5
Dribbling 7


Liam Rosenior
Overall ability 6
Shooting 5
Passing 6
Crossing 6
Tackling 6
Pace 7
Work-rate 7
Creativity 6
Heading 6
Dribbling 6

Andre Bikey
Overall ability 8
Shooting 7
Passing 6
Crossing 5
Tackling 8
Pace 7
Work-rate 8
Creativity 6
Heading 8
Dribbling 6

Shane Long
Overall ability 6
Shooting 6
Passing 5
Crossing 5
Tackling 4
Pace 8
Work-rate 8
Creativity 6
Heading 7
Dribbling 7

My own clearly biased views. Missing several players like Matejovsky and Duberry

Just based on how they are in my opinion for our team. I guess comparing them to prem players you'd have to drop them a bit, but then compared to League 2 players they are fantastic. It's difficult to do without knowing whether it's just division wide comparison or football league wide comparison. I can't see Fans of Aldershot giving players scores no higher than 3 or 4, which lets face it, in things other than workrate they arn't likely to be higher than in comparison with Ronaldo.

[Archie's penalty]

I just can't believe that BW actually did it!

[sadsack]

ALOL @ Sonko dribbling 6

If our players were as good as those ratings we'd have finished 10th.

clearly ridiculous

1st post

Hooray!!!!!!!!!!

[Elm Park]

Nicky Shorey
Overall ability-7
Shooting--7
Passing-8
Crossing-8
Tackling-7
Pace-6
Work-rate-7
Creativity-7
Heading-7
Dribbling7

all my scores are probably slightly higher than the consensus on here though

A bit harsh giving Shorey a minus 7 for shooting.

[Royalee]

Marcus Hahnemann
Overall ability-7
Shotstopping-8
Crosses-6
Distribution-4
Saving penalties-6
Presence- 7
Positioning- 7

Graeme Murty
Overall ability-6
Shooting-2
Passing-7
Crossing-6
Tackling-7
Pace-6
Work-rate-7
Creativity-6
Heading-7
Dribbling-6

Nicky Shorey
Overall ability-8
Shooting--7
Passing-8
Crossing-8
Tackling-7
Pace-6
Work-rate-7
Creativity-8
Heading-6
Dribbling-8

Kalifa Cisse
Overall ability-7
Shooting -7
Passing-7
Crossing-6
Tackling-7
Pace-8
Work-rate-8
Creativity-6
Heading-6
Dribbling-6

Ibrahima Sonko
Overall ability-6
Shooting-1
Passing-4
Crossing-3
Tackling-8
Pace-7
Work-rate-7
Creativity-5
Heading-8
Dribbling-5

Brynjar Gunnarsson
Overall ability-6
Shooting -7
Passing-6
Crossing-6
Tackling-7
Pace-4
Work-rate-7
Creativity-5
Heading-8
Dribbling-5

Leroy Lita
Overall ability-6
Shooting -8
Passing-4
Crossing-4
Tackling-4
Pace-8
Work-rate-5
Creativity-6
Heading-7
Dribbling-5

Kevin Doyle
Overall ability-8
Shooting-7
Passing-7
Crossing-7
Tackling-7
Pace-7
Work-rate-9
Creativity-7
Heading-7
Dribbling-8

Stephen Hunt
Overall ability-5
Shooting - 4
Passing- 4
Crossing-4
Tackling-8
Pace-7
Work-rate-10
Creativity-4
Heading-4
Dribbling-5

Dave Kitson
Overall ability-8
Shooting -8
Passing-8
Crossing-7
Tackling-8
Pace-6
Work-rate-9
Creativity-8
Heading-8
Dribbling-7

James Harper
Overall ability-6
Shooting-7
Passing-7
Crossing-6
Tackling-1
Pace-8
Work-rate-9
Creativity-5
Heading-5
Dribbling-5

Ivar Ingimarsson
Overall ability-6
Shooting -6
Passing-7
Crossing-5
Tackling-7
Pace-5
Work-rate-8
Creativity-5
Heading-8
Dribbling-5

Bobby Convey
Overall ability-8
Shooting-7
Passing-7
Crossing-8
Tackling-5
Pace-8
Work-rate-8
Creativity-8
Heading-6
Dribbling-7


Liam Rosenior
Overall ability-6
Shooting - 4
Passing-6
Crossing-6
Tackling-7
Pace-7
Work-rate-7
Creativity-6
Heading-7
Dribbling-6

Andre Bikey
Overall ability-8
Shooting -7
Passing-7
Crossing-7
Tackling-9
Pace-8
Work-rate-8
Creativity-7
Heading-8
Dribbling-7

Shane Long
Overall ability 6
Shooting-6
Passing-6
Crossing-6
Tackling-6
Pace-8
Work-rate-8
Creativity-6
Heading-7
Dribbling-5

[PEARCEY]

Royalee you gave Harps some high scores in there.
Bless you are a closet James Harper fan after all.

[Archie's penalty]

Royalee you gave Harps some high scores in there.
Bless you are a closet James Harper fan after all.

It's touching isn't it?

[SCIAG]

*xf*rd off
Are we talking at Championship level or a world scale? I've done Championship, knock one off if it's world ( 2 for 9s or 10s)

Marcus Hahnemann
Overall ability 9/10
Shotstopping 10/10
Crosses 6/10
Distribution 3/10
Saving penalties 7/10
Presence 7/10
Positioning 8/10

Graeme Murty
Overall ability 7/10
Shooting 5/10
Passing 7/10
Crossing 9/10
Tackling 8/10
Pace 2/10
Work-rate 8/10
Creativity 1/10
Heading 3/10
Dribbling 6/10

Nicky Shorey
Overall ability 10/10
Shooting 9/10
Passing 9/10
Crossing 9/10
Tackling 7/10
Pace 7/10
Work-rate 5/10
Creativity 7/10
Heading 1/10
Dribbling 7/10

Kalifa Cisse
Overall ability 7/10
Shooting 6/10
Passing 5/10
Crossing n/a (he's never crossed for us)
Tackling 7/10
Pace 7/10
Work-rate 7/10
Creativity 2/10
Heading 6/10
Dribbling 2/10

Ibrahima Sonko
Overall ability Either 10/10 or 1/10
Shooting 1/10
Passing 1/10
Crossing 1/10
Tackling 10/10 on his day, recently 3/10
Pace 8/10
Work-rate 6/10
Creativity 0/10
Heading 10/10
Dribbling 1/10

Brynjar Gunnarsson
Overall ability 6/10
Shooting 8/10
Passing 6/10
Crossing 6/10
Tackling 7/10
Pace 4/10
Work-rate 7/10
Creativity 2/10
Heading 8/10
Dribbling 5/10

Leroy Lita (please rate him lowly, I hate it when others describe him as our star player etc when he's fourth choice)
Overall ability 7/10
Shooting 7/10
Passing 4/10
Crossing 2/10
Tackling 1/10
Pace 8/10
Work-rate 1/10
Creativity 2/10
Heading 5/10
Dribbling 7/10

Kevin Doyle
Overall ability 10/10
Shooting 9/10
Passing 7/10
Crossing 8/10
Tackling 4/10
Pace 7/10
Work-rate 9/10
Creativity 7/10
Heading 8/10
Dribbling 7/10

Stephen Hunt
Overall ability 5/10
Shooting 2/10
Passing 2/10
Crossing 4/10
Tackling 3/10
Pace 9/10
Work-rate 10/10
Creativity 3/10
Heading 7/10
Dribbling 7/10

Dave Kitson
Overall ability10/10
Shooting 10/10
Passing8/10
Crossing 8/10
Tackling9/10
Pace6/10
Work-rate 10/10 (one of the reason we went down IMO was him working too hard)
Creativity 8/10
Heading 9/10
Dribbling 7/10

James Harper
Overall ability 8/10
Shooting 7/10
Passing 7/10
Crossing 7/10
Tackling 6/10
Pace 7/10
Work-rate 10/10
Creativity 8/10
Heading 4/10
Dribbling 6/10

Ivar Ingimarsson
Overall ability 7/10
Shooting 3/10
Passing 6/10
Crossing 4/10
Tackling 8/10
Pace 5/10
Work-rate 6/10
Creativity 5/10
Heading 10/10
Dribbling 4/10

Bobby Convey
Overall ability 7/10
Shooting 8/10
Passing 7/10
Crossing 9/10
Tackling 5/10
Pace 7/10
Work-rate 6/10
Creativity 7/10
Heading 3/10
Dribbling 9/10


Liam Rosenior
Overall ability 9/10
Shooting 6/10
Passing 6/10
Crossing 8/10
Tackling 7/10
Pace 10/10
Work-rate 6/10
Creativity 5/10
Heading 3/10
Dribbling 6/10

Andre Bikey
Overall ability 10/10
Shooting 8/10
Passing 7/10
Crossing 8/10
Tackling 10/10
Pace 9/10
Work-rate 7/10
Creativity 7/10
Heading 9/10
Dribbling 7/10

Shane Long
Overall ability 7/10
Shooting 8/10
Passing 6/10
Crossing 7/10
Tackling 3/10
Pace 9/10
Work-rate 9/10
Creativity7/10
Heading 7/10
Dribbling 6/10

James Henry

Overall ability 8/10
Shooting 8/10
Passing 6/10
Crossing 7/10
Tackling 2/10
Pace 7/10
Work-rate 7/10
Creativity 8/10
Heading 6/10
Dribbling 8/10

Alex Pearce

Overall Ability 7/10
Shooting 3/10
Passing 4/10
Crossing 3/10
Tackling 8/10
Pace 6/10
Work rate 5/10
Creativity 4/10
Heading 7/10
Dribbling 4/10

Marek Matejovsky How was he missed?
Overall: 10/10
Shooting: 9/10
Passing: 10/10
Crossing: 9/10
Tackling: 3/10
Pace:7/10
Work rate: 5/10
Creativity: 10/10
Heading: 3/10
Dribbling: 6/10

[winchester_royal]

I'll add Matejovsky....

Overall Ability 9
Shooting 7
Passing 9
Crossing 7
Tackling 6
Pace 7
Work Rate 8
Creativity 9
Heading 5
Dribbling 9

[PEARCEY]

Very generous with some of your marks SCIAG. You were very kind giving Shorey 7/10 for pace...perhaps 2/10 would be closer to the mark.

[SCIAG]

Very generous with some of your marks SCIAG. You were very kind giving Shorey 7/10 for pace...perhaps 2/10 would be closer to the mark.

Shorey is faster than that. People berate him because Utaka beat him for pace against Pompey. That day Shorey had a cold, and Utaka is fast as hell. Look at Shorey in the CCC seasons, and the start of 06/07. He's not slow.

Where else would you say I was generous? Rember I'm marking in comparion to the Championship, not the Premier League. Sonko, I suppose. However, I truely hope he'll rekindle his form of old. Henry and Pearce? Based on my former knowledge of them (aka a lot- I've been watching Henry since he was 15 and have seen most of their Football League and reserve matches) I think I've rated them fairly- though maybe Henry should be at 7/10 until he's proven.

OT, I've lurked for a while beofre getting this account activated (on my third attempt!) and so I know what you are all like.

[PEARCEY]

Very generous with some of your marks SCIAG. You were very kind giving Shorey 7/10 for pace...perhaps 2/10 would be closer to the mark.

Shorey is faster than that. People berate him because Utaka beat him for pace against Pompey. That day Shorey had a cold, and Utaka is fast as hell. Look at Shorey in the CCC seasons, and the start of 06/07. He's not slow.

Where else would you say I was generous? Rember I'm marking in comparion to the Championship, not the Premier League. Sonko, I suppose. However, I truely hope he'll rekindle his form of old. Henry and Pearce? Based on my former knowledge of them (aka a lot- I've been watching Henry since he was 15 and have seen most of their Football League and reserve matches) I think I've rated them fairly- though maybe Henry should be at 7/10 until he's proven.

OT, I've lurked for a while beofre getting this account activated (on my third attempt!) and so I know what you are all like.

Stop lurking SCIAG you''ll end up catching something contagious.
Anyway welcome to HNA young man.....and give 'em all hell.