Reading Hall of Shame?

[Deathy]

Worst ever Reading players?

[M-U-R-T-Y]

Kebe, Rougier

[PEARCEY]

Evers, Sheppard

[Winchester Royal]

Basir Savage.

[Royalee]

Kebe, Rougier, Oster, Keith Jones, Paul Smith, Simon Shepherd, Emerse Fae, Greg Halford, Sam Sodje, Alan Bennett, Michael Duberry, Keith Scott, Paul Brayson, Jimmy Crawford, Elroy Kromheer, Peter Van Der Kwaak, Scott Howie, Stuart Gray, Jim McIntyre, Mass Sarr, Byron Glasgow, Sean Evers, Robert Fleck, Andy Hughes, Ray Houghton, Martyn Booty, Paul Bodin, Michael Meaker, Paul Holsgrove, Neville Roach, Alan Maybury, Peter Grant, Martin Williams, Dean Morgan, Lloyd Owusu, Paul Brooker, Dean Gordon, Michael Dobson, Aaron Brown, John Halls, Bobby Mihaylov, Shaun Goater, Bas Savage.

[Archie's penalty]

Kebe, Rougier, Oster, Keith Jones, Paul Smith, Simon Shepherd, Emerse Fae, Greg Halford, Sam Sodje, Alan Bennett, Michael Duberry, Keith Scott, Paul Brayson, Jimmy Crawford, Elroy Kromheer, Peter Van Der Kwaak, Scott Howie, Stuart Gray, Jim McIntyre, Mass Sarr, Byron Glasgow, Sean Evers, Robert Fleck, Andy Hughes, Ray Houghton, Martyn Booty, Paul Bodin, Michael Meaker, Paul Holsgrove, Neville Roach, Alan Maybury, Peter Grant, Martin Williams, Dean Morgan, Lloyd Owusu, Paul Brooker, Dean Gordon, Michael Dobson, Aaron Brown, John Halls, Bobby Mihaylov, Shaun Goater, Bas Savage.

No for the highlighted ones - but I agree with the rest.

[Alivey]

John Halls

[PEARCEY]

Kebe, Rougier, Oster, Keith Jones, Paul Smith, Simon Shepherd, Emerse Fae, Greg Halford, Sam Sodje, Alan Bennett, Michael Duberry, Keith Scott, Paul Brayson, Jimmy Crawford, Elroy Kromheer, Peter Van Der Kwaak, Scott Howie, Stuart Gray, Jim McIntyre, Mass Sarr, Byron Glasgow, Sean Evers, Robert Fleck, Andy Hughes, Ray Houghton, Martyn Booty, Paul Bodin, Michael Meaker, Paul Holsgrove, Neville Roach, Alan Maybury, Peter Grant, Martin Williams, Dean Morgan, Lloyd Owusu, Paul Brooker, Dean Gordon, Michael Dobson, Aaron Brown, John Halls, Bobby Mihaylov, Shaun Goater, Bas Savage.

Very harsh on Scott Howie , Martin Williams and Martyn Booty. They were not that bad for us.

[M-U-R-T-Y]

John Mackie, Les Ferdinand

[rhroyal]

John Mackie? You're clearly forgetting 01/02. 1 good season is not enough for him to be remembered as a good Reading player, but it's certainly enough for him to avoid the hall of shame.

[Deathy]

Based on players I've seen in the 17 years watching Reading:

GK: Nicky Colgan (The Manor Ground defeat being the highlight. About three miss-kicks and he fained injury to pass the blame), Simon Sheppard, Adam Federici (I don't care, the guy scares the crap out of me when he plays. He's like a fatter darker kebab shop Simon Sheppard)

CB: Paul Bodin,

RB: Stuart Gray (even when he ran he looked like he was in slow motion), Andy Gurney

LW/RW: Jimmy Kebe, James Lambert

CM: Sean Evers, Emerse Fae,

ST: Keith Scott, Robert Fleck, Paul Brayson, Bas Savage, Dean Morgan

[Dirk Gently]

GK: Nicky Colgan (The Manor Ground defeat being the highlight. About three miss-kicks and he fained injury to pass the blame),

Rubbish! The picked-up ball from a throw-in and the clearance straight onto an opposing forward and into the net at Crewe were far, far, worse.

[Deathy]

GK: Nicky Colgan (The Manor Ground defeat being the highlight. About three miss-kicks and he fained injury to pass the blame),

Rubbish! The picked-up ball from a throw-in and the clearance straight onto an opposing forward and into the net at Crewe were far, far, worse.

Good memory old boy. Jesus, he was bad wasn't he! What a night that was.

[Millsy]

"You got tackled by Bodin, you got tackled by Bodin, lala la la, lala la la..."

[Royalee]

Kebe, Rougier, Oster, Keith Jones, Paul Smith, Simon Shepherd, Emerse Fae, Greg Halford, Sam Sodje, Alan Bennett, Michael Duberry, Keith Scott, Paul Brayson, Jimmy Crawford, Elroy Kromheer, Peter Van Der Kwaak, Scott Howie, Stuart Gray, Jim McIntyre, Mass Sarr, Byron Glasgow, Sean Evers, Robert Fleck, Andy Hughes, Ray Houghton, Martyn Booty, Paul Bodin, Michael Meaker, Paul Holsgrove, Neville Roach, Alan Maybury, Peter Grant, Martin Williams, Dean Morgan, Lloyd Owusu, Paul Brooker, Dean Gordon, Michael Dobson, Aaron Brown, John Halls, Bobby Mihaylov, Shaun Goater, Bas Savage.

Very harsh on Scott Howie , Martin Williams and Martyn Booty. They were not that bad for us.

Wycombe away springs to mind with Howie. Martin Williams was a sign of how poor we were at the time and Booty was utterly useless.

[Archie's penalty]

Kebe, Rougier, Oster, Keith Jones, Paul Smith, Simon Shepherd, Emerse Fae, Greg Halford, Sam Sodje, Alan Bennett, Michael Duberry, Keith Scott, Paul Brayson, Jimmy Crawford, Elroy Kromheer, Peter Van Der Kwaak, Scott Howie, Stuart Gray, Jim McIntyre, Mass Sarr, Byron Glasgow, Sean Evers, Robert Fleck, Andy Hughes, Ray Houghton, Martyn Booty, Paul Bodin, Michael Meaker, Paul Holsgrove, Neville Roach, Alan Maybury, Peter Grant, Martin Williams, Dean Morgan, Lloyd Owusu, Paul Brooker, Dean Gordon, Michael Dobson, Aaron Brown, John Halls, Bobby Mihaylov, Shaun Goater, Bas Savage.

Very harsh on Scott Howie , Martin Williams and Martyn Booty. They were not that bad for us.

Wycombe away springs to mind with Howie. Martin Williams was a sign of how poor we were at the time and Booty was utterly useless.

I loved skittles but I get your point.

[prostak]

James Lambert

Think that's a little unfair. Pissing it all away isn't the same as being out-and-out worst.

[gazzer, loyal royal]

bit harsh on Michael Dobson. only played 20 minutes, was solid for us.

Came here to do a job and mentor youngsters in the reserves

not in the hall of shame for me

[bobbybottler]

Wycombe away springs to mind with Howie.

Sheppard was consistently abysmal and was a less talented keeper than Howie but that Wycombe performance was just the pits.

[leww_rfc]

Shame on you all, Kebe is the reason we are on 6 points and not 3, he helped win that game in barnsley!!