sandman
I'll be the first to admit I've never liked Gerrard.
Thanks for clearing that up.
by Sanguine » 17 Apr 2014 12:55
sandman
I'll be the first to admit I've never liked Gerrard.
by Extended-Phenotype » 17 Apr 2014 13:02
by genome » 17 Apr 2014 13:03
by jjd82 » 17 Apr 2014 13:05
Extended-Phenotype Perhaps one of OUR best midfielders at one point, though I don't think this translated to the national team, where like others he has struggled to make a serious, consistent and long term impact.
For those reasons I think there are plenty of others who rank above him. I guess he has a more all-round game than those like Gazza or Scholes when looking at our own but I'm not convinced being an all-rounder makes you better.
At club level however, its hard to argue against such an accolade but then the pressure is off in such an arena. Your home fans will back you regardless of performance and you can pretty much play as you like without fear of critique. I think this is why players like Gerrard, Beckham, Lampard and Scholes, playing in their protected bubbles at club level, struggled to really seize the international stage which highlighted their weaknesses and found them fall short of being genuine world greats.
His time has really run out to change that.
As an aside, had Gerrard not been so loyal to Liverpool, perhaps he would have become the world class player he is often billed to be. But then his loyalty has to be admired in an industry where it is rare.
by Extended-Phenotype » 17 Apr 2014 13:22
jjd82Extended-Phenotype Perhaps one of OUR best midfielders at one point, though I don't think this translated to the national team, where like others he has struggled to make a serious, consistent and long term impact.
For those reasons I think there are plenty of others who rank above him. I guess he has a more all-round game than those like Gazza or Scholes when looking at our own but I'm not convinced being an all-rounder makes you better.
At club level however, its hard to argue against such an accolade but then the pressure is off in such an arena. Your home fans will back you regardless of performance and you can pretty much play as you like without fear of critique. I think this is why players like Gerrard, Beckham, Lampard and Scholes, playing in their protected bubbles at club level, struggled to really seize the international stage which highlighted their weaknesses and found them fall short of being genuine world greats.
His time has really run out to change that.
As an aside, had Gerrard not been so loyal to Liverpool, perhaps he would have become the world class player he is often billed to be. But then his loyalty has to be admired in an industry where it is rare.
Booooooooooooooo
by Silver Fox » 17 Apr 2014 13:24
genome I'd love to see Stevie G lift the Premier League trophy. Mostly to spite sandman.
by Ginger Ninjas » 17 Apr 2014 13:39
by Whatevs » 17 Apr 2014 13:52
by Extended-Phenotype » 17 Apr 2014 13:53
by Mr.Swainey » 17 Apr 2014 13:54
genome I'd love to see Stevie G lift the Premier League trophy. Mostly to spite sandman.
by Royalclapper » 17 Apr 2014 14:03
by YateleyRoyal » 17 Apr 2014 14:05
Royalclapper Certainly the top English midfield player of his era (and among the best in the world), better all round player than Lampard IMO.
The two from Barca have certainly been the best in the biz, somewhat helped by being in a strong club and national set up which of course they've been an integral part of. Gerrard has been the stand out player in a weaker club side though than many of the other headliners which helps highlight his quality.
Pirlo
Khedira
Alonso
Schweinstieger
Kaka (at Milan first time)
All worth mentions for varying playing roles, Gerrard could be considered in that company easily.
by stealthpapes » 17 Apr 2014 14:12
Extended-Phenotype Didn't Chelsea try and buy Gerrard at one point? Right when the Lamps/Gerrard debate was at it's peak?
Still think (as these two were sadly undropable because of the gutless string of managers this country has employed) it would have done wonders for our national team (and their standing as 'world class players') if these two played together every weekend, perhaps more so than dropping one of them would have.
by Royalclapper » 17 Apr 2014 14:19
YateleyRoyalRoyalclapper Certainly the top English midfield player of his era (and among the best in the world), better all round player than Lampard IMO.
The two from Barca have certainly been the best in the biz, somewhat helped by being in a strong club and national set up which of course they've been an integral part of. Gerrard has been the stand out player in a weaker club side though than many of the other headliners which helps highlight his quality.
Pirlo
Khedira
Alonso
Schweinstieger
Kaka (at Milan first time)
All worth mentions for varying playing roles, Gerrard could be considered in that company easily.
Khedira?!
genome I'd love to see Stevie G lift the Premier League trophy. Mostly to spite sandman.
by Victor Meldrew » 17 Apr 2014 15:15
retro_royalVictor Meldrew Nice montage by retro.
I know Blue Peter is your favourite programme and you are learning a lot from it but one day you will grow up and have to live like an adult.
In the meantime why not apply to go on Jim 'll fix it-that nice Mr Savile will help you to grow up.
Classic Scouse. Having a pop at the person pointing out how disgusting LFC fans behaviour is. Munich banners, shit throwing, murdering is all ok then I guess.
by dizzynewheights » 17 Apr 2014 15:17
dizzynewheights quite the bite there m8
by Victor Meldrew » 17 Apr 2014 16:00
dizzynewheights quite the bite there m8
by sandman » 17 Apr 2014 16:21
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 53 guests