I think the team selection against Charlton was an indicator as to how the rest of the season will be played. It looks like Sir Steve is going to give everyone a chance to prove themselves ahead of the Summer, so we could see more squad rotation than before.
Given that in most positions we would have to sell before buying how many of these players do you think will still be playing for us next season?
Bikey - definitely improved over the season, but improved enough to buy? I'm not so sure, I guess it would depend on the asking price.
Halls - Was going to leave him out as I didn't think he'd be playing before the end of the season but he's back in the reserves apparently. Has a hell of a lot to prove and not much time. Could be on his way if anyone comes in with an offer.
Sodje - not had much chance to impress here but seems to be doing well at WBA who are apparently keen on keeping him. As we've got cover in numbers in this position it might be good business to sell or do a swap deal.
DLC - I think he's done ok. It would be harsh on him to be sold but how many right backs do we need?
Gunnarson - Deserves to have played more games than he has and surely will not be sold.
Oster - Has stated he would consider a move to be able to play more first team football. Would be sad to see him go but can see it happening.
Seol - Doesn't seem to have the right mentality for this club. Think he could be sold if we get a reasonable offer.
Long - Really can't see us selling Shane, but I don't think he's ready for the Prem either. Season long loan to a Championship side would be ideal.
I wouldn't be surprised if one or two of the youngsters on loan (Golbourne, Cox, Hayes, Henry) were to make the move permanent too.
Should they stay or should they go?
-
rotherwick_royal
- Member
- Posts: 660
- Joined: 21 Sep 2006 15:08
- Location: In a field in Hampshire
-
1871 Royal
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 2677
- Joined: 24 Jan 2006 16:37
- Location: Coming to a village cricket ground near you.
Bikey - Yes. Get his signature. Will become the next sonko.
Halls - Can't really say.
Sodje - Same as above
DLC - I would say no. Halford looks good cover for murty.
Gunnarsson - Signed a new contract so yes. Very good player IMO
Oster - Yes. Maybe off in January though
Seol - No. Can't see him staying. Although he did have a better 2nd half last night.
Long - Yes. Looks very promising for the future.
Halls - Can't really say.
Sodje - Same as above
DLC - I would say no. Halford looks good cover for murty.
Gunnarsson - Signed a new contract so yes. Very good player IMO
Oster - Yes. Maybe off in January though
Seol - No. Can't see him staying. Although he did have a better 2nd half last night.
Long - Yes. Looks very promising for the future.
-
brendywendy
- Hob Nob Super-Addict
- Posts: 12060
- Joined: 04 Aug 2006 15:29
- Location: coming straight outa crowthorne
rotherwick_royal I think the team selection against Charlton was an indicator as to how the rest of the season will be played. It looks like Sir Steve is going to give everyone a chance to prove themselves ahead of the Summer, so we could see more squad rotation than before.
Given that in most positions we would have to sell before buying how many of these players do you think will still be playing for us next season?
Bikey - definitely improved over the season, but improved enough to buy? I'm not so sure, I guess it would depend on the asking price.
BUY HIM
Halls - Was going to leave him out as I didn't think he'd be playing before the end of the season but he's back in the reserves apparently. Has a hell of a lot to prove and not much time. Could be on his way if anyone comes in with an offer.
SELL HIM
Sodje - not had much chance to impress here but seems to be doing well at WBA who are apparently keen on keeping him. As we've got cover in numbers in this position it might be good business to sell or do a swap deal.
Hmmm, keep him out on loan, and see how he does
???
DONT KNOW
DLC - I think he's done ok. It would be harsh on him to be sold but how many right backs do we need?
we do need left back cover and he is pretty two footed
KEEP HIM
Gunnarson - Deserves to have played more games than he has and surely will not be sold.
MAKE HIM THE HEART OF NEXT YEARS MIDFIELD
Oster - Has stated he would consider a move to be able to play more first team football. Would be sad to see him go but can see it happening.
KEEP HIM/SELL HIM DONT CARE
Seol - Doesn't seem to have the right mentality for this club. Think he could be sold if we get a reasonable offer.
KEEP HIM
Long - Really can't see us selling Shane, but I don't think he's ready for the Prem either. Season long loan to a Championship side would be ideal.
LOAN HIM
I wouldn't be surprised if one or two of the youngsters on loan (Golbourne, Cox, Hayes, Henry) were to make the move permanent too.
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!
Last edited by brendywendy on 10 Apr 2007 15:09, edited 1 time in total.
-
Dirk Gently
- Hob Nob Super-Addict
- Posts: 11880
- Joined: 08 Sep 2005 13:54
Keep - definite potential there, Sonks Mark II in the making, with potential in midfield too.Bikey - definitely improved over the season, but improved enough to buy? I'm not so sure, I guess it would depend on the asking price.
Or even if no-one comes in with an offer! I suspect SC has given up on him.Halls - Was going to leave him out as I didn't think he'd be playing before the end of the season but he's back in the reserves apparently. Has a hell of a lot to prove and not much time. Could be on his way if anyone comes in with an offer.
Agreed, but it depends on costs - suspect he was a stop-gap (or maybe right- back cover) but is now behind Alan Bennett in the pecking order.Sodje - not had much chance to impress here but seems to be doing well at WBA who are apparently keen on keeping him. As we've got cover in numbers in this position it might be good business to sell or do a swap deal.
Keep - he's cheap and has done more than expected of him.DLC - I think he's done ok. It would be harsh on him to be sold but how many right backs do we need?
Keep - a sorely under-used nugget.Gunnarson - Deserves to have played more games than he has and surely will not be sold.
Think it's time to move on - I was singularly unimpressed on Saturday. he doesn't seem to think quickly enough for this level.Oster - Has stated he would consider a move to be able to play more first team football. Would be sad to see him go but can see it happening.
Hmmmmm. He was only bought because he was available, so I suspect SC will be happy to let him go if the money is right. Having said that, he's cheap and the shirt-sales in Korea will pay his wages.Seol - Doesn't seem to have the right mentality for this club. Think he could be sold if we get a reasonable offer.
Agree completely - great potential but needs a run in a team to gain the necessary experience.Long - Really can't see us selling Shane, but I don't think he's ready for the Prem either. Season long loan to a Championship side would be ideal.
-
riverroyal
- Member
- Posts: 255
- Joined: 09 May 2006 08:34
Bikey - Definately keep. The more he plays the better he gets. Much better than Duberry.
Halls - Get rid of him, has been a waste of time.
Sodje - Keep. havent seen much of him but has done well for WBA, so he must be useful as a squad player.
DLC - Done ok but with Halford now here, i think he will leave.
Gunnarson - Keep. Class player.
Oster - let him go. understandably he's frustrated not playing and wont really get a regular look in.
Seol - Keep. form is up and down but definately worth having in the squad
Long - Keep. one for the future. not ready for first team yet, probably fourth behind Lita, Doyle and Kitson in the striker ratings
Halls - Get rid of him, has been a waste of time.
Sodje - Keep. havent seen much of him but has done well for WBA, so he must be useful as a squad player.
DLC - Done ok but with Halford now here, i think he will leave.
Gunnarson - Keep. Class player.
Oster - let him go. understandably he's frustrated not playing and wont really get a regular look in.
Seol - Keep. form is up and down but definately worth having in the squad
Long - Keep. one for the future. not ready for first team yet, probably fourth behind Lita, Doyle and Kitson in the striker ratings
I thought Seol had a great game last night. Split the defense and got a great shot that I was actually pretty stunned didn't go in. And he worked pretty hard on defense as well. As back and forth as the game was, I was surprised he was still running in the 90th minute, but it shows he was working harder.
If that shot had gone in, he'd have basically won the game on his own, which would mark the third or fourth time he's done that this season (admittedly not in a long while). He has so many skills, I don't understand why everybody rates him so poorly.
As for the rest, I agree with the consensus. Except I don't think quite as highly of Gunnarson as others.
If that shot had gone in, he'd have basically won the game on his own, which would mark the third or fourth time he's done that this season (admittedly not in a long while). He has so many skills, I don't understand why everybody rates him so poorly.
As for the rest, I agree with the consensus. Except I don't think quite as highly of Gunnarson as others.
-
RIP ELM Park
- Member
- Posts: 195
- Joined: 14 Apr 2004 13:48
It really depends who is available as a replacement.
If we can get better players in for thier positions then they can all go. The exceptions to these are the youngsters i.e. Long and Bikey who have the potential to get alot better.
But if we were getting better players in than Soel, Oster, Halls, De La Cruz and even Gunnerson I'd not shed too many tears.
If we can get better players in for thier positions then they can all go. The exceptions to these are the youngsters i.e. Long and Bikey who have the potential to get alot better.
But if we were getting better players in than Soel, Oster, Halls, De La Cruz and even Gunnerson I'd not shed too many tears.
-
brendywendy
- Hob Nob Super-Addict
- Posts: 12060
- Joined: 04 Aug 2006 15:29
- Location: coming straight outa crowthorne
[quote="spike25"]I thought Seol had a great game last night. Split the defense and got a great shot that I was actually pretty stunned didn't go in. And he worked pretty hard on defense as well. As back and forth as the game was, I was surprised he was still running in the 90th minute, but it shows he was working harder.
If that shot had gone in, he'd have basically won the game on his own, which would mark the third or fourth time he's done that this season (admittedly not in a long while). He has so many skills, I don't understand why everybody rates him so poorly.
As for the rest, I agree with the consensus. Except I don't think quite as highly of Gunnarson as others.[/quote]
why not??!
every time he has been used in the last two seasons he has played a blinder, scored some fantastic goals(looping header last season??)
and works fantastically hard, keeps the ball, passes the ball and shoots the ball far better than sidwell, and tackles just as well.
as for seol, he has been lacking something, but his work rate was upp alot last night, he was working back to help out DLC, much improved, and more like the seol of the 1st 1/3 of the season
give him a chance to improve, as it looks as though he is slowly coming to terms with what is required[/b]
If that shot had gone in, he'd have basically won the game on his own, which would mark the third or fourth time he's done that this season (admittedly not in a long while). He has so many skills, I don't understand why everybody rates him so poorly.
As for the rest, I agree with the consensus. Except I don't think quite as highly of Gunnarson as others.[/quote]
why not??!
every time he has been used in the last two seasons he has played a blinder, scored some fantastic goals(looping header last season??)
and works fantastically hard, keeps the ball, passes the ball and shoots the ball far better than sidwell, and tackles just as well.
as for seol, he has been lacking something, but his work rate was upp alot last night, he was working back to help out DLC, much improved, and more like the seol of the 1st 1/3 of the season
give him a chance to improve, as it looks as though he is slowly coming to terms with what is required[/b]
-
Top Flight
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 3269
- Joined: 02 Jun 2006 22:46
-
Top Flight
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 3269
- Joined: 02 Jun 2006 22:46
-
Top Flight
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 3269
- Joined: 02 Jun 2006 22:46
-
Top Flight
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 3269
- Joined: 02 Jun 2006 22:46
Long is getting better with every game he plays. He is only a young lad but has enormous potential. I would definitely keep him.......
Sodje, I would release. No point. He's not good enough!
Gunnarsson, defintely keep. Great goalscorer. Great utility player. Could be Sidwells replacement for a season. I don't think we would go too far wrong if he was. Also Halford might be Sids replacement as well.
Sodje, I would release. No point. He's not good enough!
Gunnarsson, defintely keep. Great goalscorer. Great utility player. Could be Sidwells replacement for a season. I don't think we would go too far wrong if he was. Also Halford might be Sids replacement as well.
-
Top Flight
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 3269
- Joined: 02 Jun 2006 22:46
Bikey - Keep. At £1.5million he's worth a punt, and will get better with age, and has the added versatility.
Halls - Get rid. Nothing against him as I'm sure he would have been a good player given a bit of luck and a fair run in the side, but he'll be out in the summer.
Sodje - Get rid off, he's argubley our sixth choice centre back and deserves games.
DLC - Depends on where SC sees Halford playing, but I would keep him. He's been excellent for us and it's pleasing to see that if he were to leave, he would leave with his reputation held high after a rubbish spell at Aston Villa.
Gunnarson - Keep, big game player for us and could fill the void left by Sidwell.
Oster - Like De La Cruz, depends on how Halford will be deployed (right wing, right back, center midfield) but given him and SC have a gentleman's agreement, he'll most likely leave and good luck to him, again like De La Cruz his reputation will have improved and will be a wanted man.
Seol - A must keep for me, quality player who's shown his worth and is unfortunate that he'll constantly get signalled out by our fans. Best 2 footed player at the club.
Long - A player we should keep, but if we get another striker in the summer then he should be allowed to develop his talent in the Championship.
Halls - Get rid. Nothing against him as I'm sure he would have been a good player given a bit of luck and a fair run in the side, but he'll be out in the summer.
Sodje - Get rid off, he's argubley our sixth choice centre back and deserves games.
DLC - Depends on where SC sees Halford playing, but I would keep him. He's been excellent for us and it's pleasing to see that if he were to leave, he would leave with his reputation held high after a rubbish spell at Aston Villa.
Gunnarson - Keep, big game player for us and could fill the void left by Sidwell.
Oster - Like De La Cruz, depends on how Halford will be deployed (right wing, right back, center midfield) but given him and SC have a gentleman's agreement, he'll most likely leave and good luck to him, again like De La Cruz his reputation will have improved and will be a wanted man.
Seol - A must keep for me, quality player who's shown his worth and is unfortunate that he'll constantly get signalled out by our fans. Best 2 footed player at the club.
Long - A player we should keep, but if we get another striker in the summer then he should be allowed to develop his talent in the Championship.
-
LoyalRoyal13
- Member
- Posts: 95
- Joined: 17 Sep 2006 13:16
- Location: Y26 in the top flight.
Bikey - keep him! Needs a little work but a very good player in the making, another Coppell bargain
Halls - no way back I'm afraid!
Sodje - very frustrated to see him not being played. I thought he was impressive at Wigan away at the begininning of the season and really thought that he was one for the future. He has a brilliatn ability to head the ball and isnt exactly slow. I for one will be disapointed to see him leave, but I realise I am probably the minority here!
De La Cruz - definately keep him, only has a few more seasons in him at the most and I would be happy for those to be at Reading
Gunnarsson - IMHO this man should be starting alongside Sidwell week in week out, Coppell isn't an idiot he wouldn't sell Brynar
Oster - can't say he would be greatly missed
Seol - brilliant at the beginning of the season, and then what happened? Can't see a way back for the lad either unfortunately. I think he will be off in January
Long - agree with the possibility of a loan to a championship club, maybe not the whole season though...we want him back!
Halls - no way back I'm afraid!
Sodje - very frustrated to see him not being played. I thought he was impressive at Wigan away at the begininning of the season and really thought that he was one for the future. He has a brilliatn ability to head the ball and isnt exactly slow. I for one will be disapointed to see him leave, but I realise I am probably the minority here!
De La Cruz - definately keep him, only has a few more seasons in him at the most and I would be happy for those to be at Reading
Gunnarsson - IMHO this man should be starting alongside Sidwell week in week out, Coppell isn't an idiot he wouldn't sell Brynar
Oster - can't say he would be greatly missed
Seol - brilliant at the beginning of the season, and then what happened? Can't see a way back for the lad either unfortunately. I think he will be off in January
Long - agree with the possibility of a loan to a championship club, maybe not the whole season though...we want him back!
-
Readingfanman
- Hob Nob Regular
- Posts: 1369
- Joined: 14 Apr 2004 21:00
The only thing I don't agree with is the reason for SC's decisions yesterday. I believe the reason we saw change was the fact the regulars are NOT doing the job for us and he wanted to put a fire under their backsides.
This is SC trying to stir something up in his squad, it seems as if the players have accepted the fact that they are staying up and don't need to prove anything. This was his way of letting them know they have to play all the games with the same intensity as the one's them got them where they are.
I believe SC knows who will stay and who will go already and needs to get his boys back in winning form before the end of the season.
This is SC trying to stir something up in his squad, it seems as if the players have accepted the fact that they are staying up and don't need to prove anything. This was his way of letting them know they have to play all the games with the same intensity as the one's them got them where they are.
I believe SC knows who will stay and who will go already and needs to get his boys back in winning form before the end of the season.
-
Royal Lady
-
Hob Nob Subscriber
- Posts: 13760
- Joined: 14 Apr 2004 10:17
- Location: Don't mess with "my sort". Cheers then.
ESTIM8R The only thing I don't agree with is the reason for SC's decisions yesterday. I believe the reason we saw change was the fact the regulars are NOT doing the job for us and he wanted to put a fire under their backsides.
This is SC trying to stir something up in his squad, it seems as if the players have accepted the fact that they are staying up and don't need to prove anything. This was his way of letting them know they have to play all the games with the same intensity as the one's them got them where they are.
I believe SC knows who will stay and who will go already and needs to get his boys back in winning form before the end of the season.
All possible.
But I think it's simply a case of Coppell not wanting Europe and therefore using the remainder of this season to test the fringe players.
Good move I think.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot] and 239 guests
It is currently 30 Nov 2024 21:46