*LIAM ROSENIOR SIGNS, SEOL GOES OTHER WAY*

[Top Flight]

more positive vibes off the Fulham site.
http://www.fulhamfc.com/Club/Messageboa ... icID=23365

Its funny how the article at the top of the page says what a lazy inconsistent performer Seol was, yet the Fulham fans posting in seem to think its a good deal bringing Seol in.

And its funny how the Fulham fans keep stating that Rosy wasn't that good and it could be years before he is a decent right back and that whenever he played poor under Coleman he didn't get replaced because Volz was playing right midfield.

Yet both us and Fulham think we have landed stars and are happy. And you are saying more positive vibes where it don't look too positive for us or Fulham.

We both seem happy to be rid of our players......

Whats going on? Whose got the better deal out of this.

I'm sure we have the better deal and I'm sure Coppell and our coaching team will develop Rosy much quicker than the Fulham coaching team could have as they have proven so often.

[TFF]

more positive vibes off the Fulham site.
http://www.fulhamfc.com/Club/Messageboa ... icID=23365

11/09/2007 14:25:01
Mr B P location: Stairway To Heaven | Posts: 1202

You only get two to three seasons out of any player these days so you might as well get experianced players in their mid to late twenties rather than young inexperianced ones. It might take years for Liam to become a good defender, bye which time Reading will probably be relegated.

[Top Flight]

I'm sure that had he been in the team every week then he wouldn't have given two hoots about New Malden.

Not sure that would have been the case because the subject of the Korean community in New Malden kept cropping up even when he was in the team.

IIRC, when he signed he said that one of the reasons that he gave for being happy about signing for RFC was that Reading was in easy reach of New Malden. So clearly the New Malden thing was never an issue at the outset and it only became an 'issue' when he was not getting in the team.

I suppose he eventually realised that even Reading is still too far from New bloody Malden.

Its not much fun commuting in and out of London every day...... In fact its bloody horrible. I'm not surprised that Seol preferred to live in Fulham.

I think Seol is empty in the head though to be honest. He's not joining Fulham for football reasons. He is going there for an easy life. He just wants to be near his community and his Korean food. We are lucky to be rid to be honest. At least Rosenior has joined us for the right reasons. To play under a top top manager in Coppell, to play first team football and be at a much better club than Fulham to develop as a young player. Rosenior has the right attitude.

Seol's attitude stinks quite frankly. How people can't see that is beyond belief!

[SpaceCruiser]

more positive vibes off the Fulham site.
http://www.fulhamfc.com/Club/Messageboa ... icID=23365

11/09/2007 14:25:01
Mr B P location: Stairway To Heaven | Posts: 1202

You only get two to three seasons out of any player these days so you might as well get experianced players in their mid to late twenties rather than young inexperianced ones. It might take years for Liam to become a good defender, bye which time Reading will probably be relegated.

I can't take anyone who can't spell experienced or inexperienced seriously. Or even anyone who doesn't know the difference between "by" and "bye".

[Archie's penalty]

I'm sure that had he been in the team every week then he wouldn't have given two hoots about New Malden.

Not sure that would have been the case because the subject of the Korean community in New Malden kept cropping up even when he was in the team.

IIRC, when he signed he said that one of the reasons that he gave for being happy about signing for RFC was that Reading was in easy reach of New Malden. So clearly the New Malden thing was never an issue at the outset and it only became an 'issue' when he was not getting in the team.

I suppose he eventually realised that even Reading is still too far from New bloody Malden.

Its not much fun commuting in and out of London every day...... In fact its bloody horrible. I'm not surprised that Seol preferred to live in Fulham.

I think Seol is empty in the head though to be honest. He's not joining Fulham for football reasons. He is going there for an easy life. He just wants to be near his community and his Korean food. We are lucky to be rid to be honest. At least Rosenior has joined us for the right reasons. To play under a top top manager in Coppell, to play first team football and be at a much better club than Fulham to develop as a young player. Rosenior has the right attitude.

Seol's attitude stinks quite frankly. How people can't see that is beyond belief!

I think we have the better deal as well. It's better to have a committed player than someone like Seol who doesn't really care...Outside of the situation with Seol we still need creative players. Let's just hope Little is back soon and if not we have to play Oster on the right no matter what 'our' moderators say. Oster was instrumental in getting things going in our most attacking and best half of the season so far - ie the first 45 against Chelsea...

[premiership_bound]

I see Liam played right mid field in the behind close door friendly todayPerhaps he'll start that on Saturday.

Doesn't say how well he did tho but as we won 6 - 0 cant't have been that bad.
http://www.readingfc.premiumtv.co.uk/page/NewsDetail/0,,10306~1110251,00.html

[Scarface]

more positive vibes off the Fulham site.
http://www.fulhamfc.com/Club/Messageboa ... icID=23365

11/09/2007 14:25:01
Mr B P location: Stairway To Heaven | Posts: 1202

You only get two to three seasons out of any player these days so you might as well get experianced players in their mid to late twenties rather than young inexperianced ones. It might take years for Liam to become a good defender, bye which time Reading will probably be relegated.

I can't take anyone who can't spell experienced or inexperienced seriously. Or even anyone who doesn't know the difference between "by" and "bye".

Oh well done Spacedocker, aren't you clever. That post may of had a few mistakes, but it's content was far more interesting than your pointless shit.

[Royal Rother]

From Coppell's comments it seems the club instigated the move by chatting to Fulham and seeing what sort of deal could be done. Good to hear a tiny snippet of what goes on behind the scenes.

I wonder when they alerted Sunderland to the fact that possibly, just possibly Halford might not quite fit in at Reading and that if they were still interested in him then Reading might, as long as the deal made sense for us of course, be willing to listen to their offers. After all, we don't want to stand in a young player's way and it seems he really fancies playing for a more charismatic manager than Coppell, and, obviously Roy, you fit the bill...

[SpaceCruiser]

more positive vibes off the Fulham site.
http://www.fulhamfc.com/Club/Messageboa ... icID=23365

11/09/2007 14:25:01
Mr B P location: Stairway To Heaven | Posts: 1202

You only get two to three seasons out of any player these days so you might as well get experianced players in their mid to late twenties rather than young inexperianced ones. It might take years for Liam to become a good defender, bye which time Reading will probably be relegated.

I can't take anyone who can't spell experienced or inexperienced seriously. Or even anyone who doesn't know the difference between "by" and "bye".

Oh well done Spacedocker, aren't you clever. That post may of had a few mistakes, but it's content was far more interesting than your pointless shit.

I can't take you seriously either.

[Behindu]

more positive vibes off the Fulham site.
http://www.fulhamfc.com/Club/Messageboa ... icID=23365

11/09/2007 14:25:01
Mr B P location: Stairway To Heaven | Posts: 1202

You only get two to three seasons out of any player these days so you might as well get experianced players in their mid to late twenties rather than young inexperianced ones. It might take years for Liam to become a good defender, bye which time Reading will probably be relegated.

If you only get 2 or 3 years out of a player you may as well get a young player rather than one who may already have given his 2 or 3 years to someone else....

[Hampshire Royal]

I don't see what's so interesting about "Some Twat's" post. He said that you only get 2 or 3 seasons from a player. Well, that's most of our team fcuked then. He also said that it might take years for Liam to becaome a good defender. Well, yes it might, but he might also be another Nicky Shorey who was also a young inexperienced defender, who just happened to shine as soon as he got into our team. And what about Sonko, after a season adjusting to the 'Reading way' he turned into something more than a 'good' defender. And, yes, Reading may get relegated soon, but then again we may not.

Nothing interesting, original or, in fact, correct in that post

[SpaceCruiser]

So, in short, HR, you can't take it seriously either.

[Hampshire Royal]

No I can't, but I'm a bit more tollarunt of spilling mustakes than you.

[RoyalBlue]

I'm sure that had he been in the team every week then he wouldn't have given two hoots about New Malden.

Not sure that would have been the case because the subject of the Korean community in New Malden kept cropping up even when he was in the team.

IIRC, when he signed he said that one of the reasons that he gave for being happy about signing for RFC was that Reading was in easy reach of New Malden. So clearly the New Malden thing was never an issue at the outset and it only became an 'issue' when he was not getting in the team.

Your recollection isn't that far out but at that point he was looking at the better of two options in terms of travel to New Malden: Wolverhampton or Reading. Compared to Wolverhampton, Reading was in easy reach but clearly he had his heart set on getting even closer!

I though Seol was a very good player. I detested the booing of him. I think the club made a big mistake in not signing a replacement for him before they let him go. However, I recognise why Sir Steve was left with little option but to let him go and will happily join in with the booing of Seol should he ever return to the Mad Stad with Fulham.

However, I hear Kingstonian are in need of a right winger and their ground is within easy walking distance of New Malden, even for one reputed to be on the lazy side!

He left because of the idiots booing him. Hope you lot are happy now.

Of course he did Spacey, of course he did.

Did you think I was being serious?

Yes. You clearly were- hence rolling eyes rather than a wink.

[Baines]

From Coppell's comments it seems the club instigated the move by chatting to Fulham and seeing what sort of deal could be done. Good to hear a tiny snippet of what goes on behind the scenes.

I wonder when they alerted Sunderland to the fact that possibly, just possibly Halford might not quite fit in at Reading and that if they were still interested in him then Reading might, as long as the deal made sense for us of course, be willing to listen to their offers. After all, we don't want to stand in a young player's way and it seems he really fancies playing for a more charismatic manager than Coppell, and, obviously Roy, you fit the bill...

I agree. It's fascinating to get an insight into how the club arranges the deal to move the player on whilst still preserving its negotiating position so as to get a good deal for the club - as it appears to have done in both the Seol and Halford transfers.

[brendywendy]

Yes. You clearly were- hence rolling eyes rather than a wink.

More emoticon confusion
it was better without them, cause way too much trouble
emoticons are a cancer on the forum i love.

[Stranded]

more positive vibes off the Fulham site.
http://www.fulhamfc.com/Club/Messageboa ... icID=23365

Its funny how the article at the top of the page says what a lazy inconsistent performer Seol was, yet the Fulham fans posting in seem to think its a good deal bringing Seol in.

And its funny how the Fulham fans keep stating that Rosy wasn't that good and it could be years before he is a decent right back and that whenever he played poor under Coleman he didn't get replaced because Volz was playing right midfield.

Yet both us and Fulham think we have landed stars and are happy. And you are saying more positive vibes where it don't look too positive for us or Fulham.

We both seem happy to be rid of our players......

Whats going on? Whose got the better deal out of this.

I'm sure we have the better deal and I'm sure Coppell and our coaching team will develop Rosy much quicker than the Fulham coaching team could have as they have proven so often.

Isn't that the way with a lot of transfer deals though, the fans of the club player leaves are glad to see the back of them and have got a great deal whilst the new club think they've got a great player and a great deal.

[The Colonel]

Yes. You clearly were- hence rolling eyes rather than a wink.

More emoticon confusion
it was better without them, cause way too much trouble
emoticons are a cancer on the forum i love.

More quoting confusion. I didn't say that.

[Top Flight]

more positive vibes off the Fulham site.
http://www.fulhamfc.com/Club/Messageboa ... icID=23365

Its funny how the article at the top of the page says what a lazy inconsistent performer Seol was, yet the Fulham fans posting in seem to think its a good deal bringing Seol in.

And its funny how the Fulham fans keep stating that Rosy wasn't that good and it could be years before he is a decent right back and that whenever he played poor under Coleman he didn't get replaced because Volz was playing right midfield.

Yet both us and Fulham think we have landed stars and are happy. And you are saying more positive vibes where it don't look too positive for us or Fulham.

We both seem happy to be rid of our players......

Whats going on? Whose got the better deal out of this.

I'm sure we have the better deal and I'm sure Coppell and our coaching team will develop Rosy much quicker than the Fulham coaching team could have as they have proven so often.

Isn't that the way with a lot of transfer deals though, the fans of the club player leaves are glad to see the back of them and have got a great deal whilst the new club think they've got a great player and a great deal.

Well i didn't feel like that when Sidwell left.........

I certainly won't feel like that when Shorey leaves........

But I do feel like that with Seol going. What this must mean is that Fulham are getting an inconsistent, lazy lad with the wrong attitude. And according to Fulham fans we are getting a player that marks thin air, has poor positional sense and is a long way off becoming a good player.

I suppose time will tell. If they are not upset at losing him then perhaps we shouldn't be too excited about gaining him.

Same with Seol

[Stranded]

You may not have done re: Sidwell but there were certainly many on here going down the old "He wasn't that good anyway" route on virtually every thread where his name was mentioned.

It's a very common thing for fans to do and I'm not surprised some (not all) Fulham fans are doing it re Rosenior and lauding landing Seol as a great bit of business.