Shaun Cummings

[Rev Algenon Stickleback H]

Do you think even Tommy Burns would have signed this man?

No. He didn't cost enough.

[Millsy]

Bring back Andy Bernal.

[FiNeRaIn]

I called cummings out for being shit on his second game - 10 games later and he's getting worse. Solid signing BR - get rid of a former england under 21 and replace with this no mark.

[holsgrove breaks a leg]

In defence he was up against a class act in Thomas, someone i believe is premiership standard and given that he was on a free a player we should have been looking at. Having said that Cummings is fast becoming a liability with a series of nervy performances- several misplaced balls going for throw ons,little spacial awareness of who was around him when WBA pressed and giving Thomas a head start time and time again as he got caught in the trap of pursuing the attacking left back (Mattock?) leaving a gaping hole and one of our CB's having to come out of position and deal. Having started well it was only time before WBA realised Cummings positional weaknesses, pinging accurate long balls over his head onto the feet of Thomas. True he is young and is on a learning curve but i wonder whether if this is too steep. Kebe for his good and bad points wont help the development of Cummings as he offers little protection and they appear poles apart, and with Rodgers pinning his belief on Jimmy game after game i cant see any real improvement down the right.

[FiNeRaIn]

He wasn't on a free. We actually paid money for this shocker.

[Terminal Boardom]

If you are reading this Shaun, please remind us all on how you actually gave insider info on the club and players you spent a period on loan to at the start of the season and then managed to get so ripped it was as if you'd never seen them before.

D'you think they had it in for you!

Or were they the club that had actually done their homework.

I had forgotten about this. Looks as if they knew more about him than he did about them. Sadly for someone to look so bad in such a shit team is really saying something. Any more limited and he would be quoted on the Stock Exchange.

[Ian Royal]

I called cummings out for being shit on his second game - 10 games later and he's getting worse. Solid signing BR - get rid of a former england under 21 and replace with this no mark.

Ten games after his second game? How exactly are you managing to post from 21 November?

He's played 7, not knowing that just shows how worthless your opinion is. Or can you not tell the difference between him and Rosenior? I'd agree it was easy to spot he was shit at the start of the season.

[FiNeRaIn]

I called cummings out for being shit on his second game - 10 games later and he's getting worse. Solid signing BR - get rid of a former england under 21 and replace with this no mark.

Ten games after his second game? How exactly are you managing to post from 21 November?

He's played 7, not knowing that just shows how worthless your opinion is. Or can you not tell the difference between him and Rosenior? I'd agree it was easy to spot he was shit at the start of the season.

The irony in you calling my opinion worthless when you don't even go to games. Whatever, wrong figures, he's been crap every one and is the worse right back i've seen whilst I have been supporting the club.

[Bill Oddie]

I think he's better than Rosenior

Just out of curiosity, do you still share this view ?

[Stevie G]

It is hard when we rely on someone so young and inexperienced, but if that's the case then keep him as an 'academy' type and ship him out on loan. I fear Brendan doesn't want to do this as it will question his transfer 'nous', hence you'll see Shaun in the starting line up on Tuedsay, admittedly in part as we have no realistic cover for that slot, which fuels the argument as to why Brendan continues to play him and continues to cover up what is his transfer naivety!

[Southbank Old Boy]

It is hard when we rely on someone so young and inexperienced, but if that's the case then keep him as an 'academy' type and ship him out on loan. I fear Brendan doesn't want to do this as it will question his transfer 'nous', hence you'll see Shaun in the starting line up on Tuedsay, admittedly in part as we have no realistic cover for that slot, which fuels the argument as to why Brendan continues to play him and continues to cover up what is his transfer naivety!

dont forget it seems he had to get rid of Rosenoir because of the pressure on the wage bill

Cummings isnt good enough and its certainly a bad signing by Rodgers, but maybe now some will realise that Rosey wasnt that bad

[MR. CYNICAL]

As i said on another thread, Rosenior should be recalled in time for tuesday.
It's madness having no cover in that position.
What incentive has Cummings got to perform when he knows that there is no one to take his place.

[Ian Royal]

I called cummings out for being shit on his second game - 10 games later and he's getting worse. Solid signing BR - get rid of a former england under 21 and replace with this no mark.

Ten games after his second game? How exactly are you managing to post from 21 November?

He's played 7, not knowing that just shows how worthless your opinion is. Or can you not tell the difference between him and Rosenior? I'd agree it was easy to spot he was shit at the start of the season.

The irony in you calling my opinion worthless when you don't even go to games. Whatever, wrong figures, he's been crap every one and is the worse right back i've seen whilst I have been supporting the club.

The last resort of an idiot.

I have been to games, I've seen Cummings 3 times this season, that's almost half his games. Besides I'm not arguing with you about whether he's any good, just showing you up to be a total div.

[The whole year inn]

what did this guy do at Chelsea for 10 years?

have we actually signed someone who worked in the canteen at Chelseas youth ground?

[Forest Gump]

BBC report was not very complimentary. But not right to single out one player when whole team is sh!te

[winchester_royal]

BBC report was not very complimentary. But not right to single out one player when whole team is sh!te

If we'd had a competent RB we'd have won yesterday.

[Ian Royal]

BBC report was not very complimentary. But not right to single out one player when whole team is sh!te

If we'd had a competent RB we'd have won yesterday.

What a ridiculous thing to say, no matter how bad Cummings was.

[Ian Royal]

Ten games after his second game? How exactly are you managing to post from 21 November?

He's played 7, not knowing that just shows how worthless your opinion is. Or can you not tell the difference between him and Rosenior? I'd agree it was easy to spot he was shit at the start of the season.

The irony in you calling my opinion worthless when you don't even go to games. Whatever, wrong figures, he's been crap every one and is the worse right back i've seen whilst I have been supporting the club.

The last resort of an idiot.

I have been to games, I've seen Cummings 3 times this season, that's almost half his games. Besides I'm not arguing with you about whether he's any good, just showing you up to be a total div.

Oh and by the way, I've been to almost as many games as most of our STHs given our away support.

[Man Friday]

BBC report was not very complimentary. But not right to single out one player when whole team is sh!te

You obviously weren't there on Saturday. (Most of) the team was sh!te - he was a whole cesspit of cr@p all to himself.

[RoyalBlue]

As i said on another thread, Rosenior should be recalled in time for tuesday.
It's madness having no cover in that position.
What incentive has Cummings got to perform when he knows that there is no one to take his place.

Kingsley's upped his training regime!