Player of the Season Poll

[melonhead]

1. Gorkss
2. Pearce
3. Fed or Karacan

Agree with the posters, Pearce has only turned his game and gained greater confidence because of the presence of Gorkss

hes been great every time hes had a run of games in a settled defence.

[bripps]

1. Jem Karacan
2. Kaspars Gorkss
3. Adam Federici

(4. Alex Pearce)

All 4 have been awesome this year so tbh any would be a worthy winner.

[The Rouge]

Surprised to see Pearce way ahead of Gorkss to be honest.

[Maguire]

Surprised to see Pearce way ahead of Gorkss to be honest.

I reckon it's the local link (or racism, if you will)

Personally i'm amazed Karacan is so high. Just don't see it myself, although I guess fans do love a tryer.

[RoyalBlue]

A tough call this year, as so many players have impressed but I've gone for Feds. He works as hard as ever and is a spirited goalie. Lots of clean sheets, I've noticed many great saves. Of course he's part of a strong defensive setup overall but I'd like to give him my vote.

A close thing between several players but with two kids who are full paid up members of the GKU, I have to go for Feds.

[Big Foot]

1) Pearce
2) Gorkss
3) Karacan


No one else close to these 3 IMO

[Tony Le Mesmer]

Surprised to see Pearce way ahead of Gorkss to be honest.

I reckon it's the local link (or racism, if you will)

Personally i'm amazed Karacan is so high. Just don't see it myself, although I guess fans do love a tryer.

This is the same set of fans that voted Harper > Forster in our man man show season in 02/03 remember, so Im not that surprised. Not to mention Quinn being outvoted by Kerr despite scoring 40 (Forty) goals.

[loyalroyal4life]

No brainer.....Church

[Maguire]

Two examples of complete mentalism on behalf of our fans. The Harper one gr8ed with me so much as Forster clearly carried that side.

[Pepe the Horseman]

Add to that Stephen Hunt in our relegation season

[RobRoyal]

Personally i'm amazed Karacan is so high. Just don't see it myself, although I guess fans do love a tryer.

Yeah, and he's been through the Academy which is bound to give him a boost (cf Pearce).

[Vision]

Add to that Stephen Hunt in our relegation season

The irony being (given the 02/03 debacle) that Harper really should have won it 07/08.

[Z175]

Add to that Stephen Hunt in our relegation season

The irony being (given the 02/03 debacle) that Harper really should have won it 07/08.

A massive +1

[melonhead]

Surprised to see Pearce way ahead of Gorkss to be honest.

been about equal imo
, gorkss played slightly less and isnt an academy product is why AP got my vote

[Big Foot]

Surprised to see Pearce way ahead of Gorkss to be honest.

been about equal imo
, gorkss played slightly less and isnt an academy product is why AP got my vote

Pearce wins for goal celebrations alone

[RockheadRumple]

Surprised to see Pearce way ahead of Gorkss to be honest.

been about equal imo
, gorkss played slightly less and isnt an academy product is why AP got my vote

Pearce wins for goal celebrations alone

I actually think Pearce is more solid than Gorkss anyway. I've seen quite a few, although mostly very small, mistakes made by Gorkss. Misplaced passes, bad touches occasionally and *THAT* mistake vs Southampton. Don't get me wrong, I still think he's an excellent defender but if either one was to get POTS it would be Pearce for the fact that he so seldom makes these mistakes.

Also Pearce goes as nuts as I do when we score.

[PieEater]

Gorkss for me because of his sheer consistency. His arrival has turned our defence into one of the best in the Championship.

Pearce has scored some valuable goals but was average before Gorkss arrived, and still gives away a lot of possession cheaply.

[melonhead]

pearce has been great whenever hes had a decent partner- he was average alongside khumalo at the start of the season
and id say his ball retention, and passing have improved imeasurably this season, now he is confident that hes not going to have to cover his partners mistakes

[Maguire]

pearce has been great whenever hes had a decent partner- he was average alongside khumalo at the start of the season
and id say his ball retention, and passing have improved imeasurably this season, now he is confident that hes not going to have to cover his partners mistakes

Nonsense. There's a reason he wasn't breaking up that Mills/AK partnership.

He's got better by playing next to Gorkss who is, for my money, better than the other two I just mentioned.

[melonhead]

he got injured, and brian kept kish in cos we were winning games.
pearce wouldnt have made that mistake at wembley