Player of the Season Poll

[STAR Liaison]

Sorry are you saying Gorkss wasn't even in the top four!? Madness.

I'm not sure how you come to that conclusion from what I said

[Vision]

So it's official

Federici, Karacan or Pearce?

[muddyfeet]

yep

really shame about Gorkss

[Tony Le Mesmer]

How many games have Gorkks/Pearce played together in a row?

We would be nowhere this season without them. You cant say that about any of the others, despite playing so well.

But this is the same set of fans who thought Forster was not our POS in 03 and Quinn in 94. So I fully expect it to go to Andy Griffin.

[Maguire]

I just hope it's not Jem Karacan. If it is then i'm windmilling the LOT OF YOU

[TBM]

I just hope it's not Jem Karacan. If it is then i'm windmilling the LOT OF YOU

It will be Pearce

[The Rouge]

For what it is worth, here is my list, the top 3 could be in any order (and I will be happy when Pearce gets it) but I think they are the top 3. ALF hard to judge as would be higher if he had more pitch time.

1. Feds
2. Gorkss
3. Pearce
4. Leigertwood
5. Karacan
6. McAnuff
7. Harte
8. Hunt
9. Roberts
10. Cummings
11. ALF
12. Kebe

[andrew1957]

How many games have Gorkks/Pearce played together in a row?

We would be nowhere this season without them. You cant say that about any of the others, despite playing so well.

But this is the same set of fans who thought Forster was not our POS in 03 and Quinn in 94. So I fully expect it to go to Andy Griffin.

Very easy to write off other people’s views but to me the final top three is spot on.

I think Gorkks would have just edged Fed for third until the last few weeks, but Fed has been simply brilliant and won us a lot of points as the season has gone on - so for me the final vote should be:

1/ Pearce
2/ Karacan
3/ Fed
4/ Gorkks

[Maguire]

I honestly don't know what the fuss about Karacan is. It's because he runs around a lot, right?

[mr_number]

According to Fantasy Football, the top 5 is:
1) Pearce (66 pts)
2) Gorkss (52)
2) Harte (52)
4) Feds (47)
5) ALF (43)

And if that's not definitive, I dont' know what is.

[who are ya?]

I just hope it's not Jem Karacan. If it is then i'm windmilling the LOT OF YOU

[Tony Le Mesmer]

And there you have it.

Top 3 contenders are Federici, Karacan and Pearce.

Better start practicing the windmill Maguire

[Tony Le Mesmer]

According to Fantasy Football, the top 5 is:
1) Pearce (66 pts)
2) Gorkss (52)
2) Harte (52)
4) Feds (47)
5) ALF (43)

And if that's not definitive, I dont' know what is.

The top 3 in that are pretty much spot on.

[JIM]

After such a fantastic season THEY ALL should be players of the year

[loyalroyal4life]

According to Fantasy Football, the top 5 is:
1) Pearce (66 pts)
2) Gorkss (52)
2) Harte (52)
4) Feds (47)
5) ALF (43)

And if that's not definitive, I dont' know what is.

Harte? LOL

I am shocked Gorkss has not made the top 3, i thought it was a dead cert to be 1 of him and pearce

[Maguire]

According to Fantasy Football, the top 5 is:
1) Pearce (66 pts)
2) Gorkss (52)
2) Harte (52)
4) Feds (47)
5) ALF (43)

And if that's not definitive, I dont' know what is.

Harte? LOL

Fantasy Football = goals and assists, of which he's had a few

[Tony Le Mesmer]

According to Fantasy Football, the top 5 is:
1) Pearce (66 pts)
2) Gorkss (52)
2) Harte (52)
4) Feds (47)
5) ALF (43)

And if that's not definitive, I dont' know what is.

Harte? LOL

I am shocked Gorkss has not made the top 3, i thought it was a dead cert to be 1 of him and pearce

Do you want to go back and count how many match winning goals weve scored from Harte set pieces? Hint, its quite a lot.

[melonhead]

would anyone keep him?

[parky]

The winner will be announced during the club's celebration event at Madejski Stadium on Sunday 29th April.

[loyalroyal4life]

would anyone keep him?

Only as a back up left back, he will get ripped apart in the Prem, yes he has got a good delivery but as a DEFENDER he is useless, anyone who went to Saints away saw both Chaplow and De Ridder tear him apart with ease.