Wimb At the risk of upsetting Ian Harte...
Promising signing but do have to worry about why he's come to Reading if he's so highly thought of.
To go from a £15m defensive prospect being watched by Real Madrid, Man Utd and City to a holding midfielder signed by a bottom of the league side for £500k inside 2 years is a bit of a fall from grace.
Obviously teams miss talent and stock falls all of the time, but it certainly seems a gamble rather than bringing in an established talent which is what we need to be aiming for. With around an hours football all season it would be surprising to see him much this month.
The last Portuguese midfielder/defender we brought in was also pretty pants and he cost more
Anyway, hopefully it's another Long/Doyle/Shorey rather than a Cisse/Halford/Sheppard... Also few can be as bad as Ledge right now!
Some more detailed thoughts here.
http://www.thetilehurstend.com/2012/12/ ... el-carrico
Why do you put Cisse as a flop? Thought he was great tbh, particuarly in the premiership! The only reason he left was to join up with Coppell and I distinctly remember being miffed when he did go!