Best midfielder in Premier League History

[St. Brynjar]

People seem to be spunking at the thought of Fat Frank after his goals today, but who is the best PL midfielder ever? I'd say Scholes personally, but can see cases for Keane and Viera.

Anyone who suggests Leigertwood gets a slap.

[Wipped]

he really deserves a thread of his own..

your avatar creeps me out too btw.

[St. Brynjar]

he really deserves a thread of his own..

your avatar creeps me out too btw.

[Wipped]

haha, it's the only way you'd touch this!

[Lacoste]

Igor Biscan

[winchester_royal]

haha, it's the only way you'd touch this!

I give it 2 weeks till he's using your chest as a toilet

[Jackson Corner]

Scholes should have had a 100 caps for England. When Messi and Xavi say he's the best player they played against and Ronaldo the best player he has played with that should tell you something.

[AbovetheI]

Dietmar Hamann

[DandyRoyal]

The central midfielder (Giggs will always be a winger to me) with the most EPL appearances; the legendary Gary Speed, RIP

Edit: Actually thinking about it, did Speed play in the middle or on the flank? I can't remember

[gazzer, loyal royal]

I think theres arguements for Scholes, Vieira, Keane and Gerrard.

Vieira probably shades it for me. He brought so much to that Arsenal team

[genome]

Eric Djemba-Djemba

[Kitsondinho]

Scholes, hands down. The way successive England managers treated him was criminal. Hoddle was the only one who used him in his best position.

[sandman]

The central midfielder (Giggs will always be a winger to me) with the most EPL appearances; the legendary Gary Speed, RIP

Edit: Actually thinking about it, did Speed play in the middle or on the flank? I can't remember

So great you can't remember what position he played in.

[Albert Spangler]

It's so obviously Paul Scholes that it's a daft thread.

[Badger Finger]

'greed

[St. Brynjar]

haha, it's the only way you'd touch this!

I give it 2 weeks till he's using your chest as a toilet

Winchester Royal knows the score.

[Big Foot]

Mods, please merge viewtopic.php?f=3&t=72310

[St. Brynjar]

Mods, please merge viewtopic.php?f=3&t=72310

Why are they the same topic? One is discussing a particular footballer, one is discussing the position in general.

[Big Foot]

They're both about Frank Lampard, m8.

[St. Brynjar]

They're both about Frank Lampard, m8.

It's also about Keane, Vieira, Scholes and Gerrard etc.