Most Under rated player for Reading

[JC]

Ollie Kearns

[Reading4eva]

Scott Taylor - Was a quality player who would get in our team now.
Kevin Watson - I rated him from the word go.

Most overrated would be Pog - Might as well be working in McDonalds.

[LoyalRoyalFan]

Marek Matejovsky
Kevin Watson
Lee Nogan

[melonhead]

marek is one of the most overrated, and thats me speaking as someone who actually loved him

[St. Brynjar]

Zurab Khizanishvili hands down.

[Rollerbob]

John Salako and Marcus Hahnemann

[SCIAG]

marek is one of the most overrated, and thats me speaking as someone who actually loved him

Marek is underrated because he was really overrated and everyone jumped on the "hate Marek" bandwagon, then he kept getting injured and couldn't prove the h8rs wrong.

People forget his good games (which were really good) because he spent so long out injured and got sent off against Blackburn and because Rodgers misused him.

[LoyalRoyalFan]

He would do a job for us now, though.

[stealthpapes]

Marek's finest hour was when he wanged a Czech hooker right up her hurt locker.

Apparently he played a bit for us. It wasn't that he was rubbish, it was just ...

no

he was rubbish

[NewCorkSeth]

Jimmy Kebe

[melonhead]

jimmy kebe


but only by fools

[sandman]

marek is one of the most overrated, and thats me speaking as someone who actually loved him

Marek is underrated because he was really overrated and everyone jumped on the "hate Marek" bandwagon, then he kept getting injured and couldn't prove the h8rs wrong.

People forget his good games (which were really good) because he spent so long out injured and got sent off against Blackburn and because Rodgers misused him.

And the other players weren't "on his wavelength".

[Tilehurst End]

Bob Lenarduzzi

[imHobb]

Nick Blackman

[peterroyal76]

Ricky Newman

[Handsome Man]

Having just looked at his thread, it's Kebe. Best player we have had since the 2006 team, scored goals, tackled back, had a vanishingly small proportion of poor games and entertained me more than anybody.

Marek was the worst player in the club's history. If you are an attacking midfielder with more assists for the opposition than your own team then you really should retire. I did love that period when he played for Rodgers' side, though. But even then he still always oxf*rd it up in the end, like a Tourette's person who you know is eventually going to swear but can still be tremendously engaging and polite in the time between obscenities.

[Millsy]

Having just looked at his thread, it's Kebe. Best player we have had since the 2006 team, scored goals, tackled back, had a vanishingly small proportion of outstanding games and entertained me more than anybody.

Corrected for you.

[Cripple Creek]

Mark White

[SouthSmallRoyal]

Loads of you will disagree but I'd say Simon Church.

Good striker and when the likes of Kitson, Lita and Doyle went he took his opportunity very well, remember his goals against Crystal Palace and Preston in 2009/10? Great finisher, quick and could play in a partnership role or maybe on his own. Either way, I don't think he was given much of a chance after that season, always on the bench. Glad to see him doing well at Charlton, now!

[Fluff]

Mark White

+1 for Chalkie