I don't really think Cummings was any better than Kelly, they both looked dodgy. Kelly has a better track record and is ultimately our best full back, so he gets the nod.
If we are serious about being a passing side, we can't use Akpan in a midfield two. Maybe as the most advanced in a midfield three, but he's way down the pecking order there.
Sharp and Pog both played well against Charlton, and I see no need to change anything (except for bringing Gunter back in).
Finally, there is no point selecting three wingers plus Blackman. This limits our options.
With that in mind, here is my team:
----------------McCarthy-----------------
Gunter----Pearce----Gorkss-------Kelly
McCleary--Guthrie--Williams--McAnuff
----------Pogrebnyak--Sharp-------------
Subs: Federici, Cooper, Cummings, Tshibola, HRK (Drenthe if fit), Obita, Le Fondre
If we want to go one up front then HRK shouldn't be in the hole. Put Obita or McAnuff there, or play 4-5-1 with Tshibola allowing Guthrie to sit deep.