Hendo I think AWB has made the most successful tackles this season so to say his defending is just OK is a bit of a stretch.
Going forward he could certainly improve, his crossing success is only 14% from over 100 crosses which isn't great, but 4 assists from right back is fine, so far from utterly useless.
Don't really know enough about Williams, other than the fact that he is young and looks pretty energetic when playing. Thought Shaw looked back to his best before he got his injury this year.
More to defending than tackling though, think he’s just a bit too naive and rash
Given United have had no proper RW this season, they really do need more from AWB going forward. 4 assists is an OK figure, but I’d like to see a breakdown of those figures to see the sort of assists he makes
Admit it may be a bit harsh on Williams who I think is predominantly a RB but every time I’ve seen him play, he’s looked out of his depth
I think if United’s aims are just to reach the top 4, then players like AWB will suffice. But I think they need more if they want to challenge for the title again