Reading FC Match Report: 2023/2024 Season - League One
CARLISLE 1 READING 3
Reading: S Smith (17), H Knibbs (36), H Knibbs (57)
Carlisle: J Mellish (71)
Post Match Fans' Opinion
PieEater
» 02 Mar 2024 22:36
Prematch we had a walk around Carlisle and I have to say I liked it, lots of great historic buildings, parks, rivers, and a some decent pubs. The sun was out an it was a lovely day, it did cloud over and rain later but we made it to the ground dry.
This team will stay up and do well if they stick together, we eased off at 3-0 and let them back into it but never really looked under the cosh. Femi loved the adoration after being subbed, I hope he stays.
Oddly we saw Lewis Wing walking down outside the offfy by the station after the game, people getting selfies with him. Not sure how he missed the coach.
WestYorksRoyal
» 03 Mar 2024 10:18
The change of position for Knibbs has been absolutely crucial.
If the season ended now, I'd have Knibbs 1st and Wing 2nd in POTS. This squad just makes me more desperate for a takeover, I want to see this squad and Selles get us through our darkest moment and push on and win promotion in the next few years (next season probably too soon though).
Fezza
» 03 Mar 2024 10:26
The change of position for Knibbs has been absolutely crucial.
If the season ended now, I'd have Knibbs 1st and Wing 2nd in POTS. This squad just makes me more desperate for a takeover, I want to see this squad and Selles get us through our darkest moment and push on and win promotion in the next few years (next season probably too soon though).
This is somewhat harsh on Azeez, Bindon and Craig IMHO - to be honest they've all been immense in giving us a fighting chance when it would have been easier to bemoan the situation the club is in.
WestYorksRoyal
» 03 Mar 2024 10:31
If the season ended now, I'd have Knibbs 1st and Wing 2nd in POTS. This squad just makes me more desperate for a takeover, I want to see this squad and Selles get us through our darkest moment and push on and win promotion in the next few years (next season probably too soon though).
This is somewhat harsh on Azeez, Bindon and Craig IMHO - to be honest they've all been immense in giving us a fighting chance when it would have been easier to bemoan the situation the club is in.
Not sure it's harsh. There can only be one POTS so you can't fit in all the team. It's good that for once it's actually debatable, instead of Tom Ince winning by default. Who even won in 2022? Also probably not deserving.
Young POTS is very crowded this year. Azeez is only 22 and the front runner for me, but Bindon has been great and crazy that Craig is an outsider.
Mid Sussex Royal
» 03 Mar 2024 11:11
Only moans, slow start again and almost cost us early on, and a poor 15 min spell after we scored the third.
Mbengue getting better but makes me nervous still at times, decision making sometimes not great, difficult one for Selles whether he brings back Holmes as he could be fit next week.
Snowflake Royal
» 03 Mar 2024 11:20
This is somewhat harsh on Azeez, Bindon and Craig IMHO - to be honest they've all been immense in giving us a fighting chance when it would have been easier to bemoan the situation the club is in.
Not sure it's harsh. There can only be one POTS so you can't fit in all the team. It's good that for once it's actually debatable, instead of Tom Ince winning by default. Who even won in 2022? Also probably not deserving.
Young POTS is very crowded this year. Azeez is only 22 and the front runner for me, but Bindon has been great and crazy that Craig is an outsider.
I think I might even have Craig and Bindon above Wing. Wing does the spectacular. But Craig and Bindon just do the unglamourous but importsnt work brilliantly, week in, week out.
To have two academy players in basically their debut season be standouts is exceptional. Then there was Abbey too.
Honestly not sure how to place it this year.
WestYorksRoyal
» 03 Mar 2024 11:59
Not sure it's harsh. There can only be one POTS so you can't fit in all the team. It's good that for once it's actually debatable, instead of Tom Ince winning by default. Who even won in 2022? Also probably not deserving.
Young POTS is very crowded this year. Azeez is only 22 and the front runner for me, but Bindon has been great and crazy that Craig is an outsider.
I think I might even have Craig and Bindon above Wing. Wing does the spectacular. But Craig and Bindon just do the unglamourous but importsnt work brilliantly, week in, week out.
To have two academy players in basically their debut season be standouts is exceptional. Then there was Abbey too.
Honestly not sure how to place it this year.
I can see the point of view, but you need players with the attacking X face who can do the spectacular, otherwise we'd be a workmanlike team without the quality to win games, which would almost certainly relegate us this season.
Snowflake Royal
» 03 Mar 2024 12:34
I think I might even have Craig and Bindon above Wing. Wing does the spectacular. But Craig and Bindon just do the unglamourous but importsnt work brilliantly, week in, week out.
To have two academy players in basically their debut season be standouts is exceptional. Then there was Abbey too.
Honestly not sure how to place it this year.
I can see the point of view, but you need players with the attacking X face who can do the spectacular, otherwise we'd be a workmanlike team without the quality to win games, which would almost certainly relegate us this season.
To put it another way, I think Wing is at his level in L1, but Craig and Bindon will spend most of their careers well above it.
blythspartan
» 03 Mar 2024 13:08
I can see the point of view, but you need players with the attacking X face who can do the spectacular, otherwise we'd be a workmanlike team without the quality to win games, which would almost certainly relegate us this season.
To put it another way, I think Wing is at his level in L1, but Craig and Bindon will spend most of their careers well above it.
I appreciate it’s very unlikely, but if we were to ever get back into the Premiership Craig is a player who could play at that level in my opinion. Sadly, we’ll most likely lose him in the summer.
Snowflake Royal
» 03 Mar 2024 13:12
To put it another way, I think Wing is at his level in L1, but Craig and Bindon will spend most of their careers well above it.
I appreciate it’s very unlikely, but if we were to ever get back into the Premiership Craig is a player who could play at that level in my opinion. Sadly, we’ll most likely lose him in the summer.
Think we should get at least one more season out of him (with new owners).
To play right at the top for long I think he needs to add more of a change of tempo to move the ball forward quicker sometimes, and some goals, or at least a shot.
WestYorksRoyal
» 03 Mar 2024 13:59
I appreciate it’s very unlikely, but if we were to ever get back into the Premiership Craig is a player who could play at that level in my opinion. Sadly, we’ll most likely lose him in the summer.
Think we should get at least one more season out of him (with new owners).
To play right at the top for long I think he needs to add more of a change of tempo to move the ball forward quicker sometimes, and some goals, or at least a shot.
If we get good owners in, we can absolutely convince talented young players to stay. Every time you move you take a risk it may not work out, the best way to progress is to be with a club who can take you places. A new owners' ambition should be top half with playoff aspirations in 25, serious promotion contenders in 26, holding our own in the Championship by 28. Young players would stay unless we fall behind that or they get an offer that is simply too good to refuse.
stealthpapes
» 04 Mar 2024 08:58
So whoever recommended the Settle-Carlisle line gets a gold star, just bliss. For all the moorland, the best bit was up in the Eden valley and snow-capped hills looming large out of the cloud. Like a fantasy film.
Walk down to the ground - lovely old fashioned one. Huge support. A bit more tense than necessary. What was ultimately a fairly routine 3-1 win felt like a lot closer. I don't think they were any cop - we lost our heads for 10-15 minutes at 3-0 and let them back in.
Three Little Birds was great and perfectly judged.
Checked in to station hotel then had a wander - The Boardroom, Kings Head, The Appletree, Thin White Duke, Hotel bar - for a solid evening and then the most obscene fish and chip shop dinner I've ever had - cumberland sausage and chips. Somewhere a horse is limping.
Sunday. Rail replacement to Workington, train to Ravenglass, sat with a sarnie and ice cream overlooking the estuaries. Beautiful. Back on the train - think that estuary just before Barrow is pretty spectacular as well. Along the coast, again, lovely as the sun went down, and a rapid one home.
Match Stats
Full Time: 1-3
Half Time: 0-2
Attendance: 7891
Referee: Martin Coy
Teams
Reading: D Button, A Yiadom, T Bindon, C Mola, A Mbengue, M Craig, H Knibbs, L Wing, F Azeez (K Abrefa, 89), K Ehibhationham (B Elliott, 66), S Smith.
Subs not used: J Pereira, C Savage, H Dean, J Wareham, P Mukairu
Carlisle: H Lewis, S Lavelle, J Mellish, J Armer, J Ellis, P Huntington, H Neal, J Vela (A McCalmont, 59), T Charters (J Gibson, 59), L Armstrong, J Diamond (D Butterworth, 79).
Bookings / Red Cards
Reading: --
Carlisle: --
League One on 02 March 2024
This League One game took place 276 days ago in the 2023/2024 season.