Match Report: 2010/2011 Season

16 October 2010: CHAMPIONSHIP
READING 0 SWANSEA CITY 1
goals
Reading: -
Swansea: Sinclair (35 mins).
Half Time: 0-1.

Attendance: 18,418

CHAMPIONSHIP 16 Oct 2010
Pos Team P Pts GD
9 Leeds 11 17 -1
10 READING 11 16 +4
11 Millwall 11 16 +2
teams
Reading: Federici, Mills, Harte, Griffin, Armstrong, Khizanishvili, McAnuff, Kebe, Karacan, Robson-Kanu (Hunt, 66), Long (Church, 76). Subs not used: Howard, Pearce, Cummings, Antonio, McCarthy.
Swansea: De Vries, Tate, Williams, Monk, Rangel, Pratley, Gower (Cotterill, 20), Sinclair, Orlandi, Dyer (Serran, 85), Dobbie (Nouble, 76). Subs not used: Beattie, Makaba-Makalamby, van der Gun, Taylor.
bookings
Reading: Armstrong.
Swansea: Cotterill, Pratley, Rangel.
Ref: O Langford.
report
As far as Brendan Rodgers is concerned this was a perfect day. Not only did his team take all three points and move above Reading into the top six, but he was also given a warm welcome by the Reading fans early in the game. His team played some neat football and crucially had more of a cutting edge than the Royals. For Reading fans it was a disappointing and frustrating game in which all the obvious weaknesses were exposed. As far as strikers are concerned the statistics speak for themselves. What is remarkable is the strike record in spite of the lack of goals from the front men. Once again Karacan and Armstrong enabled Reading to dominate midfield for most of the match but without opening up the visitors defence. The back four were comfortable in possession but distinctly uncomfortable when confronted by pacy forwards. Griffin, Harte and Khizanishvilli played their part in keeping the ball and initiating attacking play with good passing. With McAnuff trying with limited success to fill Sigurdsson's role, a lot depended on Robson-Kanu and Kebe to break down City's defence, and today they simply were not up the job against a well organised and tightly packed defence. Both players had their moments, but when they did get behind the defence and deliver, the cross was either poor or the forwards were unable to convert them into goals.

Reading started well stealing the ball immediately form the kick-off and pressing City back into their own half. City survived an optimistic appeal by Reading for a penalty. Twice in the opening ten minutes Reading troubled City with crosses from the right from Kebe and Karacan to Long, the latter being header just over the bar. Reading then had a sight of goal when a clearance ricocheted to McAnuff in the box but his shot was blocked. Apart from the noise generated by The visiting fans it developed into a fairly subdued contest. City retained possession well an the Royals pressed without success. City took the lead with a well executed goal on the break in the thirty-fifth minute. Cotterill ran at the back four, which was real problem all afternoon, and spotted Sinclair breaking done the left. Griffin was alert to the danger but from a starting position of yard or two ahead of Sinclair was unable to catch him. Ironically, had he held the line with the rest of the back four Sinclair would probably have been caught offside.

Reading had been on the front foot for most of the first half and they certainly needed to get at City with greater urgency after the interval. Robson-Kanu briefly flickered into life having been anonymous in the first half but it was City however that created better chances in the first phase of the second half. Reading were sliced open on the flanks by fast wingers and penetrating passing. Mills and Khizanishvilli were not quite or sharp enough to cover the weakness and Reading were lucky not find themselves further behind. Dyer hit the bar when he broke clear and found himself with only Federici to beat and almost immediately afterwards Dobbie found himself in a similar position. On this occasion Federici was able to block the shot. A City corner almost produced the second goal but the ball dribbled wide. Reading looked totally distinctly rattled but recovered their composure and began to press for the equaliser. It was one of those days when Reading did not look like scoring. Pressure created a few chances mainly headers but Long, Church and Hunt all failed to convert their chances. Kebe, having received his Player of the Month Award was disappointing. Eventually he gave up trying to beat his man and crossed from deep positions which made it easier for De Vries and his defence to deal with. Reading needed a player on the bench to come on to provide a spark in midfield but that option was simply not there.

At the final whistle City celebrated with their fans, Brendan Rogers applauded both sets of fans and Reading trudged off despondently. Thankfully the home fans did not turn on their own team which is fair because they had tried their hardest. On this showing both teams could make the play-offs but neither look likely to win promotion.
John Wells
FANS' POST MATCH OPINION

Shame we only really seemed to do anything with the ball in the final third during the last ten minutes. McAnuff i don't think was at the races today but every now and then showed glimpses of what we frustratingly know he can do. Dyer was too much for Harte, every single time - my idea would have been to bring Hunt on for Harte and move Armstrong to left back and reshaping the midfield a bit. Thought their number 8 (?) did a good job of deceiving the referee and making some late tackles today, wasn't impressed. Must say though, Mills and Zurab did well today IMO - shame about them being caught out of position for the chances Swansea had - that must be worked on. All in all i think 0-1 was probably fair despite our end to the game, improvements (and a speedy striker) needed IMHO.
tomrfcurz

We weren't awful, we were simply outplayed in every part of pitch. They looked like they wanted it and we didn't - we looked like the mid-Championship team that we are. Dyer should've had a hat-trick. We must close down players better than we did today too. And we can't afford to squander the (few) chances we were given. Whoever is writing for the OS today must be on drugs. The 'official' match report starts: "The Royals were on top for the majority of the game, but couldn't find that elusive goal." Brian, please bring in a f*cking striker on-loan FFS.
John Peel

Got an opinion? E-Mail us at opinion@royals.org
Appropriate submissions will appear on match report pages
QUOTES FROM THE PRESS

Scott Sinclair continued his hot streak in front of goal as Swansea boss Brendan Rodgers enjoyed a 1-0 win over former employers Reading. Rodgers was dismissed from the Madjeski Stadium hotseat last term after less than half a season in charge. But the ex-Watford boss seems to have been rejuvenated after taking the reins at Swansea in the summer and the south Wales outfit leapfrogged Reading to move into the npower Championship play-off places courtesy of their third consecutive away win. Reading enjoyed the better of the early exchanges but the Swans settled into a slick passing rhythm to establish control midway through the first half. Their pressure was rewarded when Sinclair got the better of Royals goalkeeper Adam Federici to claim his ninth goal of the season. Nathan Dyer rattled the crossbar for Swansea in the second period before they were forced to withstand a late surge of Reading pressure.
Sporting Life