READING 1 SCUNTHORPE 1 Attendance: 6,142
Scorers: Hunter Date: 27 November 1999
Team: Whitehead (Howie), Murty, Bernal, Hunter, Polston, Gurney (Brayson), Parkinson, Caskey, McIntyre, Forster (Smith), Lisbie.
Audio: Supplied By Classic Gold:
0-1: Scunthorpe's Hodges Scores
1-1: Hunter makes it 1-1
Pardew ponders lack of courage
Pardew: As poor as I can remember...
Match Hero: Polston

This was more of the same horrific football from Reading that we've seen all season, but if anything it's getting worse. Reading are continuing on their downward path, a path which seems to have no end as Reading push on nowhere but down. And after this match, yet another dismal Reading performance, the fans have had enough. Attendances are dropping and we're almost down to the "hardcore" support already. The fans were excellent to begin with - giving the Royals as much support as they could possibly hope for, but after showing a complete inability to score and then going one down it all spilled over, and to be honest the players probably deserved the on-slaught from the crowd. Even some of the West Stand were on their feet chanting "We Shit, and we're sick of it". Pure depression is slowly being replaced by expressed frustration. Who to blame though? A large number of the East Stand were ready for a pitch invasion demanding us to stop playing shit - but how? The management clearly don't know the answer - it's a problem they've inherited - but something drastic has to be done to stop the slide of many seasons.

With Reading's lack of recent goals in stepped Libie up-front, Reading's new loan signing from Charlton. Playing alongside Forster and McIntyre it at least looked like Reading were out there for the three points. But it was Scunthorpe who got off to the best start and it was a miracle that they weren't a goal up inside the first couple of minutes. A corner was won on the right and fired into the Reading box. The first shot was blocked, leaving a second chance, just right of centre, for a shot on goal. It was going in but was somehow cleared off the line to safety.

It looked even worse for the Royals on 15 minutes when Whitehead collapsed on the edge of the box after pumping the ball up-field. After treatment he continued with Howie warming up, only to have real problems dealing with a clearance moment later and collapse yet again after stuggling to kick it wide. He'd clearly done his leg in trying to hoof the ball and was replaced by Scott Howie. There were some nervous few moments when Howie first came on in his familiar number one shirt, he came late to an advancing forward which could have cost a goal, but from then on he didn't do much wrong.

Scunthorpe's good start quickly came to an end as Reading appeared to be taking control of the game. For a while I thought we were actually looking quite good. If we'd managed to put one in the back of the net it might have been a different story. Unfortunately Reading just weren't dangerous enough, and we're so low on confidence we were clearly scared to shoot. At the back Polston was clearing things up very nicely indeed, but he needed to put in a few vital tackles on more than one occassion as other members of the defence were left stranded. His distribution out from the back of defence also should have taught other members of the side a lesson or two.

Up front Lisbie was looking everything he'd been hyped up as being. Looking similar to Martin Williams both on and off the ball he was bloody fast and showed some great touches on the ball. He's apparantly been banging them in left, right and centre for Charlton Reserves - but he must have quickly inherited the Reading disease and failed to get a first half shot on target. We weren't looking too bad, but it was to turn out to be the same old story - not creating enough chances. Reading lacked the speed, skill and desire. When we did make chances they were wasted. Every time. McIntyre, again getting plenty of support from the Reading fans, wasted a great opportunity to give Reading the lead. He broke into the area on the left and was faced with just the keeper between him and the net. Instead of firing home he appeared to be caught in two minds and an attempt that was probably a cross sped low right across goal and way wide on the right.

Forster was replaced within the first half. I assume he was injured but it may have been tactical too as the three man forward line hadn't produced the early goal that was perhaps the game plan. Smith came on to replace Forster and play just behind the front two of McIntyre and Lisbie.

Scunthorpe appeared to be settling for the draw and put everyone behind the ball. Scunthorpe, not one of the most skillful sides in the division were content to foul whenever something looked like happening and Reading seemed all to happy to sink down and respond with the same treatment. Scunthorpe were also forced to replace an injured player within the first 45 minutes and although there were six minutes of stoppage time there could have been more.

And once again the second half continued as the first had. Scunthorpe looked more and more prepared for the draw and Reading couldn't find a way through despite the superior possession, and once again it decended into frustrating dullness as it appeared to be drifting towards nil-nil once again. Lisbie has a great opportunity to put Reading ahead when we did break through but was too scared to do it. He had two clean attempts to put it away. He did very well to beat his man and pull the ball inside to set up the shot, but instead chose to pull it back when it would have been simpler to let fly.

With Pardew still clearly after the victory Brayson was brought on with 20 minutes left - a real opportunity it seemed at the time. Brayson mustered one long range shot from outside the box which was well wide to the right of the goal, and then Reading went a goal down and Brayson once again didn't get a sniff of goal.

Scunthorpe's goal could be seen coming way before it happened. Once again a textbook style break-away goal. Reading should have been able to defend it, but weren't. The away side broke down the right. Reading successfully pulled a few men back, but Scunthorpe did better. The ball was threaded from right to left into the box, and then again to the left of centre to the spare unmarked man - with Hunter unsure which direction to go in. The shot was fired across the outstretched Howie and into the far corner of the net. A straight forward enough goal that we should have defended. And then Reading just collapsed as Scunthorpe threatened to stretch their lead further.

Howie kept the score down with a superb outstretched save from a free-kick just outside the box. Moments later Scunthorpe were clean through yet again. This time Howie reacted instantly and, when he looked to be second favourite for the ball, came legging it out brilliantly to block the shot and save a goal. The game was then reduced to farce with Hunter appearing to bite the leg of the Scunthrope number 25 and getting a punch in the head for his troubles. The number 25 was lucky not to go as he's already picked up a yellow card.

At this point there was only one team in it: Scunthorpe. Reading threatened to let at least one more in and the East Stand could take no more. "We're shit, and we're sick of it, we're shit..." and of course "You're not fit to wear the hoops". Some idiot behind me tried (obviously unsucessfully) to start a chant demanding the departure of John Madejski. Mr. Madejski is the one thing holding Reading together at the moment. If Madejski ever decieded he wasn't enjoying the ownership of Reading FC then he could just leave, then there would be no-one to absorb the huge loss we make every single week - an increasing loss as the gates continue to shrink. Without him we would be nothing, and Reading Football Club would cease to exist. People should try and remember that.

Then with just three minutes left of the clock Reading scored the equaliser to win back a point. The ball was crossed from the right by Caskey and Hunter was there at the far post to rise and head the ball home.

Hunter's late equaliser almost certainly saved the Madejski Stadium's first ever pitch invasion, and provided the first bit joy of the afternoon for the home fans - after 87 minutes of play. The travelling Scunthorpe fans will feel very hard done by after almost making it 0-2 with so many chances after they'd taken the lead. Scunthorpe remain one of the poorer sides of the division but almost got away with the full three points. The draw against Burnley mid-week seemed almost acceptable but this result entirely wasn't. In the end we were almost pleased to get a point. At this rate Division Three football looks more likely than unlikely.

Post Match Opinions

Well having traveled down from Cambridgeshire again with my 10 year old 'Young Royal' daughter (£20.00 petrol plus the rest of the days costs) I don't think I'll be doing that for a while. The first half we did look OK, usual stuff good build up lousy final ball, wasted opportunities, and despite Lispie's nice touches I thought maybe we could see why he is only a Charlton Reserve - hopefully he will be able to hit the target soon..... Second half more of the same until they scored, then panic and worse football than you could hope to see in Sunday league. We were very lucky to get a point, their no.25 was very lucky to stay on the pitch, the punch was clear from the West stand families enclosure, if Hunter had bitten him and the ref saw it, as no 25 said after the game, then they should both have walked, if he didn't see the bite how could he miss the punch? Up to that point he had been a reasonable ref, if a bit lenient, to both us and them in a fairly dirty game. It will be a while before I spend another £50.00 for that standard of football! -- Steve Pardoe

This is my first season as a season ticket holder, and although I do not regret getting one it is hard to justify why I got one. This season has been a depressing state of affairs. The expectation that goes with the amount of money spent and the stadium means that anything other than promotion would have been disappointing, but the way we are heading at the moment is worse than disappointing it is a disaster. Something must be done. No-one can blame Mr. Mad he has invested alot of money into the club and last season I think I am right in saying we spent more money than the rest of the division put together. No-one can blame the management yet, they have inherited a massive problem of over-paid poor players from the Burns era. The only way we are going to get outta this mess is if Mr. Mad yet again dips into his pocket and buys some more players..if he adopts the sell before we buy attitude we are in big trouble as no-one is going to buy the crap players we have got and that means we will be letting go of the half decent ones thus meaning an even shitter team. Us, the fans, need to show that we are not happy about the situation. I think that the "pants" idea that has been suggested on the HNA discussion board is worth a go, but there is no point only a handful of fans doing it, we must be together for the cause. Much more of this and I can see Mr. Mad leaving us and this would mean one thing only: READING FC RIP. -- Christopher Backwith

I'm sorry but I've reached my limit of pain and suffering - I can't take anymore. A loyal royal since 1970, I cannot remember ever having to see such a clueless, inept, non inventive and under-committed team. Saturday is put in perspective when you remeber that prior to this Scunthorpe had lost their last 3 on the trot letting in 12 goals. It makes you long for the 'glory-days' of Ian Porterfield - we were crap then too but at least we were mid table and seemed to put some effort in. Its just too depressing for words and I've had enough. -- Simon Curtis

Abysmal, truly abysmal. However what I find more worrying is that it was not in isolation- we have been playing this bad for weeks, if not months. We seemed to start quite lively but began to falter after only 15 minutes. This allowed an extremely physical Scunthorpe side to take control of the game. We seemed unable to defend against a side that were one of the poorest teams I've seen at the Mad' stadium, with my main concern being Hunter; what has happened to him? Is it just me or has he lost the plot- biting players legs and attempting to strangle the opposition and his aimless long ball clearances that rarely come within 10 feet of a Reading player are laughable. I can only think of three players in the team on saturday who are good enough to keep us up this season and this causes me great concern. I totally agree with the comments concerning Madjeski. I too heard some idiot shouting for his 'resignation' . Do they not understand? Whether you like him or not, without him we are nothing. My biggest fear is that he loses patience with the club. That would be the end of Reading FC and we should never forget it.....-- Warwick.

Quite where Reading Football Club goes from here I do not know. Forget the 'point gained', this was everything you've come to dread about Royals' performances over the last 2 years. Not only was there, unforgiveably, no passion but no tactical awareness and very little skill on display. Scunthorpe had read the script and knew exactly what needed to be done to get a result at the Madejski - depressingly little. It would be difficult to pinpoint problem areas, things are wrong everywhere. We were predictable up front, toothless and uninventive in midfield and, particularly after the Scunthorpe goal, woeful in defence. There's not a great deal more to say, but here's a sobering thought; At one point the majority of the East Stand were singing 'Stand up if you're sick of this...' and a few even managed a chorus of 'Pardew out!' - once the faithful few (and we are now down to that as far as attendances are concerned) start voicing their dissaproval in this way those on the payroll at Reading Football Club had better start to take note. -- Steve Morris

Got an Opinion?
Comment on this, or any Royals match - email opinion@royals.cx
Appropriate submissions will appear on match report pages!